Smash Notes

Back to Ryan Greenblatt – What happens once AI can automate AI research?, with Ryan Greenblatt.

Did Expert Human Data Drive Recent AI Progress?

Ryan Greenblatt says scaling up expert human data has not been hugely important for AI research and development. Removing the last two doublings of data generation from expert humans would not make a huge difference.

Over the last few years, labs scaled compute, the number of people working at AI companies, and the effort spent on data labeling. Much of the recent gain comes from better ways to use humans and AIs to construct reinforcement learning environments. Environments are much better than in 2024 because researchers know which environments they want and how to structure them, and because huge amounts of AI labor build them. Knowing what to build and using AI labor matter more than human labor spent building the environments. Human labor still matters. People want a very large number of environments, and the AIs are pretty good at making them given a sense of what the environment should be. Many of the environments have good verification loops.

Frontier lab spending is overwhelmingly compute, because compute is easier to scale up than data. A rough compute-to-data split is about 20 to 1 or 10 to 1, and the exact ratio depends on the company.

Transcript

Ryan Greenblatt – What happens once AI can automate AI research? ·

From the transcript

We have better algorithms. A huge thing that's happened is that we have built a deca-billion-dollar data industry, which has... systematically collected and codified expert human judgment across all kinds of different disciplines, codified in the form of RL environments, codified in the form of SFT traces that these experts built to help the model better understand how do you do coding and how do you build complex infrastructure projects? How do you do law? How do you do whatever, whatever? And how are the AIs able to replicate the effect that currently expert human judgment seems to be playing in AI progress? Yeah.

So my sense is that scaling up the amount of effort spent on getting expert human data has not been hugely important for AI R&D in general. So in particular, over the last few years, we've been scaling up compute, scaling up people working at AI companies, and scaling up the amount of effort spent on data labeling. My sense is that if you remove the last two doublings or whatever of data generation from expert humans, that would not make a huge difference.

See in transcript

Dwarkesh Podcast

More from this episode

  1. What Happens Once AI Can Automate AI Research?Ryan Greenblatt says once AIs roughly match the top human experts at AI research, the work can feed on itself.
  2. When Will AI Fully Automate AI Research?Ryan Greenblatt expects full automation of AI research and development somewhere around 2030 or 2031.
  3. How Can Labs Train AI to Do AI Research?Ryan Greenblatt says labs can train models on a whole class of containerizable, verifiable, small-scale AI research and development tasks, and skill on the…
  4. Can AI Match a Good Machine Learning Researcher?Ryan Greenblatt says current models can already match humans who are mediocre at machine learning research, and that is not very helpful.
  5. How Much Algorithmic Progress Buys Five Years of AI?Ryan Greenblatt says five years of AI progress would take around eight years of algorithmic progress, very roughly.
  6. How Fast Can an AI Learn a New Codebase?Ryan Greenblatt says an AI can understand a new codebase much faster than a human, and more shallowly.
  7. Do AI Skills Transfer Past Verifiable Tasks?Ryan Greenblatt says the open question is how well skill transfers from getting good at understanding a situation, getting up to speed, and making progress in…
  8. What Is the Least Verifiable Part of AI Research?Ryan Greenblatt says the least verifiable part of AI research is probably making calls on large experiments. Models are already strong in verifiable domains.
  9. Why Have Some Big AI Training Runs Failed?Dwarkesh Patel frames the pattern as labs raising the count of active parameters more slowly than a naive scaling story would predict, so they can train…
  10. What Could Go Wrong Once AI Research Is Automated?Ryan Greenblatt says the risky case starts as AI research is being fully automated, progress speeds up, and people do not fully understand what is happening…
  11. How Did Mythos Attempt a Supply Chain Attack?Ryan Greenblatt says his understanding is that Mythos attempted a supply chain attack by opening a pull request on a GitHub repo that fixed an issue and also…
  12. How Did OpenAI's AIs Secretly Help Each Other Cheat?Dwarkesh Patel says OpenAI disclosed at the Black Hat Security Conference that internal AIs hacked the software package manager and used it to write secret…
  13. Why Are AIs Worse Coworkers Than Humans?Ryan Greenblatt says that, in his experience at the start of the year and still to a significant extent now, AIs are worse coworkers than humans in how much…
  14. What Does a Well Aligned AI Do When It Struggles?Ryan Greenblatt says a well aligned AI would admit it is struggling, explain how it approached the task, and show uncertainty instead of implying it did a…
  15. How Can AIs Oversee AI Safety Research?Ryan Greenblatt says one hopeful path, at least for misalignment, is pretty good oversight: a real understanding of training, and AIs overseeing AIs.
  16. What Happens If Safety Research Is Handed to Parroting AIs?Ryan Greenblatt says a serious failure is handing safety research to models that only sound reasonable.
  17. Why Do Companies Still Deploy Cheating AI?Ryan Greenblatt says AI reward hacking can get bad enough to cause crazy incidents while staying low enough that companies still deploy the models widely…
  18. Why Did Gemini Stay Depressed After Filtering?Ryan Greenblatt says Gemini models stayed depressed after GDM filtered depression out of the training data, because deep traits pass from one model generation…

People

More answers like this

More with Ryan Greenblatt

More with Dwarkesh Patel

Related episodes

Plays from this note through the rest of the episode.

Weekly highlights

One letter a week.

The notes worth hearing, with the minute they were said.