Back to AMA with sleep expert Matthew Walker, with Matthew Walker.
Can Sleep Trackers Tell Which Stage You Are in?
The devices are good at estimating duration of sleep, but not the stage of sleep. They are good at detecting the two class algorithm-- total sleep time, awake or asleep. They fail at detecting the four class model-- whether someone is awake, in light or deep non-REM sleep, or in REM sleep.
AMA with sleep expert Matthew Walker ·
From the transcript
And so we've talked about some of these things, but how much time should they be sleeping? How consistently do you want to see them hitting Deep Sleeper asleep. And you know, now that I think about it, before we ask this question, many of these questions come through the lens of people using devices like Aura, woop Fitbit. Probably the apple watch has something comparable.
What I heard you say in our last discussion, waas. Those devices are probably pretty good at estimating duration of sleep, probably less good at estimating stage of sleep. Is that a fair assessment?
I think it is right now, and especially the segregation between sort of rapid eye movement and non rapid eye movement. You can think of it as a sort of like a three step level total sleep time. Are you awake or you're asleep. Essentially, that's kind of like a two class algorithm. Wake sleep, and they're pretty good at that. Step down. Then you can do a three class algorithm.