Smash Notes

Back to #438 James Garfield's Extraordinary Rise, with David Senra.

Why Did James Garfield Refuse to Praise Poverty?

David Senra says James Garfield refused to praise poverty because he refused to romanticize his childhood. His extraordinary rise from fatherlessness and abject poverty made him the embodiment of the American dream, and he was raised in desperate circumstances.

James Garfield's father died just a few months after his 33rd birthday, in a log cabin he had built four years earlier. The cabin had one room, three small windows, and a rough wooden plank floor. Gaps between the logs were filled with clay in a futile attempt to shut out the brutal Ohio winters. His father's death left his mother with four children to feed and debts she could not hope to pay. James Garfield, the youngest, was not yet two. She sold much of their land and farmed what was left with help from her oldest son, his 11-year-old brother. James Garfield did not have a pair of shoes until he was four years old. He understood clearly that he was poor and had inherited an innate dignity from his mother.

As a young boy asking to go to school, he did not expect anyone to ask what kind of coat he wore if he got through a course of study, and if they did he would not be ashamed to tell them it was a ragged one. He saw no path to college while he had to support himself and work, so he left home at 16 and became a canal man. Born in poverty in a log cabin, he had no way to predict how his life would turn out. He already knew education was how he would get out.

Grokipedia·David Senra·Ohio

Transcript

#438 James Garfield's Extraordinary Rise ·

From the transcript

And just like James Garfield says, I owe him a salute because I know not what possibilities may be buttoned up under his coat into his future. There's no way Garfield could have predicted when he was a young man being born in poverty into a log cabin that his life would turn out the way it did. And so let's go into his early life, since James Garfield's father died just a few months after his 33rd birthday.

He would die in a log cabin that he had built four years earlier. It consisted of one room, three small windows, and a rough wooden plank floor. The gaps between the logs were filled with clay in a futile attempt to shut out the brutal Ohio winters. His father's death left his mother, Eliza, with four children to feed. Their youngest son, James, was not yet two years old.

See in transcript

Founders

More from this episode

  1. How Did James Garfield Pay for School?David Senra says James Garfield paid for school by working as a janitor after he could not afford tuition.
  2. What Cause Would James Garfield Not Fight?David Senra says James Garfield would fight almost any cause except his own political future.
  3. Why Did James Garfield Hate Being President?David Senra says James Garfield hated being president because office seekers filled his days, while the work he wanted was to sit in the Library of Congress…
  4. Why Did Doctors Reject Joseph Lister's Antiseptics?David Senra says doctors rejected Joseph Lister's antiseptics even though the death rate among his surgical patients immediately plummeted.
  5. Why Did James Garfield Die From a Harmless Bullet?David Senra says James Garfield almost certainly would have survived if doctors had left the bullet alone.

People

More answers like this

The other side

More with David Senra

More with James Garfield

Related episodes

Plays from this note through the rest of the episode.

Weekly highlights

One letter a week.

The notes worth hearing, with the minute they were said.