Did AI Solve the Riemann Hypothesis?
No. Alex Kontorovich says the Riemann hypothesis is not solved. He wants its solution, and he did not expect to see, in his lifetime, the kind of progress that arrived a few days ago.
He will grant, for the sake of argument, what he calls the solved axiom. It says any mathematical problem a human can solve together with AI can also be solved by AI alone. He says we are nowhere near that point, and he does not expect to reach it. In that world, the only way to make progress is to press a button. The system thinks about the problem. It does not have to solve every problem.
Even then, he argues, it would not destroy pure mathematics. A theorem matters because it lives in human heads, not only as ones and zeros in a data center.
#503 – AI Crisis in Math: Navier-Stokes, Riemann Hypothesis & Complexity Theory ·
From the transcript
Yes, accept the first move. That's no longer fun. And we don't see many games of centaur chess anymore, right? And so, in fact, I just had a conversation with a colleague named Thomas Goberta where we axiomatized our argument for what the future might look like. And one of the axioms that I'm willing to even accept for the sake of argument is what I call the solved axiom.
And the solved axiom says, let's assume at some future point, we're nowhere near there now, and I don't expect us to be there necessarily. We'll see where the capabilities taper off if they do. But let's assume the solved axiom, which says any mathematical problem that can be solved with human interacting with AI could also have been solved by AI alone.