Why Is the Doorman Fallacy Useful for Math and AI?
Ankur Moitra treats the doorman fallacy as a good way to think about mathematics in the age of AI. The fallacy boils a complex job down to the simplest, most visible task and misses the value that is harder to articulate.
A doorman appears to hold the door for people coming and going. In New York, he enjoyed talking with the doorman, and a sliding door that detects arrivals and departures would miss the parts of the job that add a lot of value. The simplest visible part of a mathematician's job is proving theorems, including conjectures left open for hundreds of years, like Fermat's last theorem. A mathematician is someone who thinks deeply. Proving old conjectures is a byproduct. The work also builds new theories, new ways of looking at old things, and new conceptual connections. AI might swallow the less visible work too, but mathematics is not there yet.
The moment is momentous, and it is the wrong time to hit the panic button. It is the right time for the field to recenter on its values and talk about them. The work has a plurality of aesthetics and goals. When problem solving for well-defined problems becomes cheap, the goals orthogonal to problem solving become much more valuable.
#503 – AI Crisis in Math: Navier-Stokes, Riemann Hypothesis & Complexity Theory ·
From the transcript
So, you know, I'm a mathematician. I'm a theoretical computer scientist. But I've also been reading a little bit more broadly, you know, about social sciences, just to sort of make my peace with all of the changes that have been happening. One of the things that really stuck in my mind that I liked is there's something called the Dorman fallacy, which is very interesting.
So the idea is that you take a complex job and you boil it down to its simplest, most visible task. So what does a doorman do? I guess they hold the door for people as they're coming and going. Right. And when we lived in New York, we really enjoyed talking to our doorman. You know, they were wonderful people. But, you know, if you digest it down to just that simple job, you can think, oh, I can replace them just by a sliding door that detects when people are going or coming.