How Long Have Autonomous Weapons Existed?
Palmer Luckey says autonomous weapons have existed for thousands of years. He defines them as weapons that carry out what you program them to do, independent of the operator or the engineer, and he says a new set of technology is only making them better.
Dave Blundin asks who unleashes the weapons if drones fly instead of pilots, and whether that call is made on the aircraft or sent back to headquarters. Palmer Luckey says the change is not as large as people think. Weapons have been making their own kill decisions for decades. The Aegis system on destroyers has a fully autonomous mode. Flip a button and it shoots down anything inside a programmed range, with no human confirmation. CIWS and SeaRAM can do the same against incoming missiles, mortars, artillery, and speedboats. In Vietnam, aircraft launched missiles that flew over the horizon, looked for the radio signal of a surface-to-air missile site, and struck it. A person still chooses the area and the signal.
He also points to pitfall traps that let people walk across and then catch the heavier commander on a horse, poison traps that kill people with some traits and not others, or that spare animals, and many land mines, sea mines, and torpedoes. Myths about golems sent to fight or defend a city fit the same idea. His argument is that autonomous weapons have been around for a very long time.
From the transcript
So think like agriculture or textiles. You can buy two weeks of calories for less than one hour of federal minimum wage labor. That's crazy. Let's give it up for Palmer here. You're going to see that for everything. Dave. So I got a really pressing question on my mind. I'm kind of a feeds and feeds and chips and AI foundation models guy. And so when you're putting systems in the field, weapons in the field, you can put the intelligence inside it.
And this has always been a big problem for the Air Force. Like if we're going to start flying drones instead of pilots, who's going to unleash the weapons? And how's that decision going to get made? And the downside of transmitting it back to headquarters is you have latency. The upside is you have a lot more compute. What you can put locally in a device in a robot in the field in a plane is limited, but it's really, really fast.