Why Does Rich Sutton Call Synthetic Data a Big Mistake?
Rich Sutton says synthetic data is not a general method that uses computation. He calls it a big mistake, and maybe the next big lesson. The idea has floated around Alberta for five or ten years. He calls it the big world hypothesis, which Khurram Javed later wrote up: the world is incredibly big, there are infinitely many things to learn, and the world is massively more complex than any agent because it contains many other agents.
Humans still decide which synthetic data is good, so the method stays bottlenecked by experts. A short program can only describe a small world. It will not match the real world, and it cannot tell you what is happening in another person's mind or how a drone's motors wear against a physical environment. An agent that learns from its own experience can repair a wrong model by continuing to learn. A human-built simulator changes only when people notice that it is wrong.
Rich Sutton and Khurram Javed: Why AI Models Stop Learning, and How to Start It Again ·
From the transcript
Can I just push on this a little bit? Yeah. It seems like a lot of what the Foundation Model Labs are working on right now is synthetic data generation in order to kind of get us beyond the fossil fuel that is the existing human internet. Is synthetic data generation kind of as part of this LLM scaling paradigm, is that a general method that leverages computation? No.
Why? That's just a big mistake. Why? Well, it's such a big... Maybe it's the next big lesson.
It's been floating around Alberta for five or ten years. Okay. And we call it the big world perspective or the big world hypothesis. Kuram, who eventually wrote it up as a paper. There's a little paper called the big world hypothesis. The big world is... that the world is incredibly big. There are infinitely many things to learn. And you can have people generating these synthetic data sets, but there would always be more things to learn.