Smash Notes

Back to 2026 Midterms: Promises vs. Economics.

Why Do Down Payment Subsidies Raise Home Prices?

Bethany McLean was struck that nearly everybody has a housing plan. Mike Rogers would let borrowers defer student loan payments while saving for a down payment. Ken Paxton promises a $50,000 deduction for a home down payment. She asked whether any of these proposals really fix the fundamental issue.

Luigi Zingales said they do the opposite. If supply is not very elastic and does not respond much to prices, as happens when people cannot build, giving a subsidy to demand will only increase prices. Subsidizing demand is a terrible idea. What is needed is to make supply more elastic, and that means touching the interests of homeowners, a large constituency among Democrats and Republicans. He called it a delicate topic.

Transcript

2026 Midterms: Promises vs. Economics ·

From the transcript

I was struck by that, that nearly everybody has a housing plan. Mike Rogers would let borrowers defer student loan payments while saving for a down payment. Ken Paxton promises a $50,000 deduction for a home down payment. But do any of these proposals really fix the fundamental issue?

No, I would say the opposite. If you know that the supply is not very elastic, so it doesn't respond very much on prices, as it is the case if you cannot build, giving subsidy to the man will only increase prices. So that is the terrible idea to subsidize demand. What you need to do is make supply more elastic. But that means touching the interest of homeowner, which is a pretty big constituency and both among the Democrats and the Republicans.

See in transcript

Capitalisn't

More from this episode

  1. Why Is Promising to Bring Prices Down Reckless?Bethany McLean asked whether bringing prices down is even the right objective.
  2. Why Do Few Candidates Offer a Federal Debt Plan?Luigi Zingales said the U.S. deficit is starting to be worrisome, and that the country will need to be more fiscally disciplined.
  3. Why Does a Janitor Lose Money Moving to New York?Luigi Zingales said the cost of housing is one of the main reasons the country does not see more internal mobility that helps lift all boats.
  4. Should Credit Card Interest Be Capped at 10 Percent?Bethany McLean asked about a federal 10% cap on credit card interest rates. Luigi Zingales noted that even Trump is campaigning on it.
  5. Should Data Centers Pay Their Own Power Bills?Bethany McLean pointed to bipartisan overlap on constraining data centers. Democrat Annie Andrews wants to propose a two-year moratorium in South Carolina.
  6. Did Trump Adopt Modern Monetary Theory?One panelist says Trump basically adopted modern monetary theory, so anyone who supports the theory has to support part of what Trump is doing.

People

More answers like this

Related episodes

Plays from this note through the rest of the episode.

Weekly highlights

One letter a week.

The notes worth hearing, with the minute they were said.