Smash Notes

Back to Public Choice and Politics Without Romance (with Mike Munger), with Mike Munger.

Why Does Government Action Fail to Represent the Will of the People?

Government action is the outcome of a complex set of institutions and norms along with the incentives that the individuals inside face. There is no reason to think government action will reflect what people want because people almost always want different things.

Transcript

Public Choice and Politics Without Romance (with Mike Munger) ·

From the transcript

And, and lastly, The other piece of this romance, which, I think it's important to put on the table, is that the romance we have about democracy, whichever system we're in, you're living in a republic, I'm living in a parliamentary democracy here in Israel,

it's very easy to remember some of the, flaws of these two systems, but the, I think the conceptual thing to, to focus on is that it does not, what government does does not represent the will of the people.

it, it is the outcome of a complex set of institutions and norms that, and the incentives that the individuals inside those institutions and norms face, and there's no reason to think that it will reflect What people want, and even more strongly, people almost always want more than, they don't want the same thing. So what could it possibly mean to say it reflects the will of the people? What it does is it reflects an imperfect, by definition, process by which group decisions are going to have to get made.

See in transcript

EconTalk

More from this episode

  1. Why Does Liberalism Require Tolerance and Humility?Liberalism requires that people forbear from acting as if they know they are correct.
  2. Why Does the Munger Test Replace the Word State With Donald Trump?The Munger test shows how support for having the state decide what people can say on the internet disappears when Donald Trump replaces the word state because…
  3. Why Does Politics as Exchange Fail to Scale Beyond Small Groups?Politics as exchange succeeds in small groups because participants like each other and share information about preferences and allergies while possessing…
  4. Why Does Methodological Individualism Assume the Locus of Choice Is the Individual?Methodological individualism assumes the locus of choice and the locus of enjoyment or disappointment is the individual.
  5. Why Does Public Choice Differ From the Street View of Politics?Public choice and the street view of politics clash because the street view of politics tends to assume that people will rise above the incentives.
  6. Why Does a United States Senator Fail to Do the Right Thing?Competition disciplines corporations but re election disciplines US senators.
  7. Why Do Florida and South Dakota Keep Foreign Sugar Out?Senators from Florida and South Dakota support sugar import restrictions because sugar cane and sugar beets grow in Florida and South Dakota.
  8. Why Has Congress Passed So Few Laws?The United States Congress has passed very little legislation in the last close to 10 years because the incentives that now face the United States Senate and…
  9. Why Does Liberalism Require Wielding Persuasion Instead of Power?Liberalism is a constrained vision.

People

More answers like this

More with Russ Roberts

Related episodes

Plays from this note through the rest of the episode.

Weekly highlights

One letter a week.

The notes worth hearing, with the minute they were said.