Back to Public Choice and Politics Without Romance (with Mike Munger), with Mike Munger.
Why Does the Munger Test Replace the Word State With Donald Trump?
The Munger test shows how support for having the state decide what people can say on the internet disappears when Donald Trump replaces the word state because there is no such thing as the state. The people who run the state are the same people who run corporations. Public choice requires comparing a real market setting with a real government setting to avoid romance about perfect government incentives.
Public Choice and Politics Without Romance (with Mike Munger) ·
From the transcript
I've proposed immodestly the Munger test as a way of thinking about public choice. The Munger test is, and this happens all the time, and I've had people get quite angry at me for doing this,
which, as you might imagine, happens often. So they'll say, I think the state should be in charge of deciding what people can say on the internet. And I'll say, wait, stop,
take out state because it doesn't exist, and put in Donald Trump, and see if you still believe it. Oh, no, no, absolutely not. Well, there's no such thing as the state. That's a romantic notion. The people who run the state are the same people who run corporations. Now, they may face different incentives, they may behave differently, but in terms of self-interest and their ability to get information and the incentives that they face, we have to put them in a context where we're comparing a real market setting with a real government setting, and then see if you believe it.