Can AI Formalize a Proof a Human Already Wrote?
Alex Kontorovich says autoformalization is basically solved, and not in the way he wants. A sorry-free proof of a theorem human beings have already written on paper is, in his view, a finished problem.
The library work is not finished. People will still put in thousands of hours, in the open, building a library of mathematics, and the byproducts that help a person understand a theorem still come from that work. He still wants that open library work, and he says the work stays very difficult. He had already been through one shock about a month earlier. After Labor Day the next shock was Navier-Stokes. He calls the quasi-Riemann result round three.
#503 – AI Crisis in Math: Navier-Stokes, Riemann Hypothesis & Complexity Theory ·
From the transcript
Right. Do a breakthrough. Yeah. Do, do, do a breakthrough. Do a breakthrough. That's the prompt. And it goes and does it. Of course, you never know from a company perspective. There's a lot of incentive to sort of sell it as that, even though there might've been a lot of intermediate steps that led with any stages of the training or maybe some things left unsaid, even though the final prompt is do a breakthrough.
There could be a lot of groundwork before that, that led to, we don't know. So I remember that was a Friday because I just was completely like my mind was completely exploded and it was labor day. And we, we just took the kids to the beach and I needed a few days of, you know, I'm not checking my phone. I'm not on Twitter. I'm just throwing, you know, throwing my kids into the ocean.