What Did AI Prove About Navier-Stokes?
Steven Brunton says the proven result is the forced version on the Clay website, one of four versions, not every Navier-Stokes problem. Smooth external forcing is arranged so terms cancel and a vortex forms, and the construction only works in three dimensions.
The AI proof builds a specialized vortex that stretches and thins until the radius is infinitely small, like a figure skater pulling their arms in during a spin. Energy in the fluid stays finite, while the flow at that filament blows up and the vorticity becomes infinite. Physical intuition says viscosity should damp that growth. Mathematicians only started to think a counterexample was possible about 15 years ago.
Day-to-day engineering is unchanged. Fluids are as hard to simulate and predict as they were a month or two ago, whether the job is an airplane wing or an artificial heart.
#503 – AI Crisis in Math: Navier-Stokes, Riemann Hypothesis & Complexity Theory ·
From the transcript
We have other examples, kind of simpler problems that are like Navier -Stokes that do blow up. So the simplest one is just a simple, ordinary differential equation, if you don't mind me taking a little tangent. So x dot equals x squared. x is the state of my system. x dot just means the rate of change of x in time. And if that rate of change of x is growing proportional to x squared, that differential equation does blow up in finite time.
So it just takes a quadratic non -linearity. Think about if I have, you know, x dot equals x. This is like x could be the population of bunnies. And we know bunnies like to populate. x dot equals x grows exponentially. You know, the state of my bunny population in time will grow exponentially. It'll get bigger and bigger and bigger. It'll double and double and double.