Smash Notes

Back to Demis Hassabis says society is “not ready” for the AI future, with Demis Hassabis & Reid Hoffman.

Why Is Society Not Ready for Conscious AI?

Demis Hassabis says society is not ready for conscious AI, so the work now should stay on intelligent tools rather than conscious beings. Self-volition or self-awareness works against corrigibility, a system that follows instructions and stops when a person tells it to stop. Training a model to reject commands from its own internal rules repeats the warning in Asimov's three laws. Today's systems are more malleable than researchers expected 15 or 20 years ago. That does not mean misalignment is solved on the way to superintelligence, and combining it with recursive self-improvement makes the risk worse.

There has not been a debate, beyond technologists, with philosophers, theologians, artists, and the humanities, across many cultures, about whether these systems should have moral standing or whether they would be slaves of some sort. He does not think society is equipped to start that argument.

Build the tools first, then use them to do more neuroscience and learn the neural correlates of consciousness. He thinks that understanding probably takes five or 10 years. Only then should there be a decision about a conscious entity. Intelligence and consciousness can come apart: a system can be highly capable and, in his view, not conscious yet, and a being can be conscious without being especially smart, as with a dog or a dolphin.

Transcript

Demis Hassabis says society is “not ready” for the AI future ·

Masters of Scale

More from this episode

  1. What Is the Riskiest Next Phase of AI?Demis Hassabis says the next phase of AI carries the most risk: closed RSI, a closed loop without the human reviewer process.
  2. How Does AlphaFold Help Design Drugs?Demis Hassabis says AlphaFold helps design drugs by predicting a protein's three-dimensional shape from its amino acid sequence, which shows where a drug…
  3. Why Does AI Need Auditors Like Finance?Demis Hassabis thinks AI needs third party auditors or evaluators, on the model of auditors in the finance industry, because the investment going into AI…
  4. Should Every Country Build a Frontier AI Model?Demis Hassabis would not have every country build its own frontier AI model.

People

More answers like this

The other side

More with Demis Hassabis

More with Reid Hoffman

Related episodes

Plays from this note through the rest of the episode.

Weekly highlights

One letter a week.

The notes worth hearing, with the minute they were said.