Smash Notes

Back to John Coogan, Co-Founder & Host at TBPN, with John Coogan.

Why Did Lucy Gum Grow So Slowly?

John Coogan says Lucy gum took 10 years to reach the size of Soylent because marketing stayed much more targeted on purpose, which meant way lower growth rates, and the company did not really want to be mega viral. Nicotine gum is age-restricted and FDA-regulated, and the claims a brand can make are very important, including whether anyone can say the gum helps you quit smoking. A lot of things cannot be said. Soylent was a food product, generally recognized as safe by the FDA, and people can decide what they eat all day.

He worked very closely with the co-founders for almost a decade, is still on the board, and is still working with them. They grew the business a lot, but Lucy never went viral and never appeared in the New Yorker. They watched Juul go super viral and get a bunch of kids addicted, and that was a huge risk they did not want. Lucy was meant to be the anti-Juul and the anti-cigarette. The customer was smokers trying to quit who thought Nicorette tasted bad, was hard to find, and felt like medicine, along with the post-vape community that had picked vaping up in college and later did not want to vape around family.

The slower path followed from that targeted plan. Getting to Soylent's size took 10 years.

Grokipedia·Lucy·John Coogan

Transcript

John Coogan, Co-Founder & Host at TBPN ·

From the transcript

Just to clarify, that batch didn't break YC. It broke the YC partners who were working with that batch. There weren't enough. There weren't enough. And we hadn't sharded. So every partner had to know about all 86 companies. So just to clarify. Yes, yes, yes. Okay. Talk about quaint though. I mean, 86 companies. That's quaint. Yeah. So what happened with Lucy? So Lucy went through a similar arc actually.

So I worked very closely with my co -founders for– I mean, I guess I was– I mean, I'm still on the board. So I'm still working with them. But almost a decade. And we grew that business a lot. Never had the same experience as Soylent. Like never went viral. Never was in the New Yorker. And a lot of that was because we had a very different strategy.

See in transcript

The Social Radars

More from this episode

  1. Why Did John Coogan Leave Soylent?John Coogan left Soylent because the company was pretty mature, he was running e-commerce, and the business no longer needed a software team.
  2. Why Did John Coogan Stop the Documentary Sale?John Coogan stopped climbing toward a sale of a documentary to Netflix or HBO because the money was not enough and the film would become a hit piece.
  3. How Do You Cover Tech News Without the Right Guest?John Coogan had no idea the show would be live, no idea it would be daily, and no idea it would amount to a modern television show.

People

More answers like this

Related episodes

Plays from this note through the rest of the episode.

Weekly highlights

One letter a week.

The notes worth hearing, with the minute they were said.