Smash Notes
Anthropic Goes Public, Nvidia in Crisis, Markets Tank, Open Source Crackdown? artwork

All-In

Anthropic Goes Public, Nvidia in Crisis, Markets Tank, Open Source Crackdown?

Chamath Palihapitiya, Jason Calacanis, and David Friedberg cover Anthropic's $2 trillion IPO and $107 billion raise, Nvidia's $2 trillion drop after Jensen Huang's exit, and a possible open-source disclosure rule. Palihapitiya expects about ten dirt-to-application megacorps and reads buybacks as a warning. Calacanis stays long on all-day agent use, and Friedberg opposes labels that could lock in closed models.

Notes

  1. Chamath Palihapitiya expects nine to 10 megacorps to be built over the next decade because of AI, each one running from the application layer all the way down… Full answer

  2. Jason Calacanis says Anthropic went public the day of the taping, hit a $2 trillion valuation, and raised over $107 billion, with the green shoe filled and… Full answer

  3. Chamath Palihapitiya says spending free cash flow on buybacks is a tell that leadership does not know what to buy, what to build, or what to invest in. Full answer

  4. David Friedberg says Anthropic has been growing beyond internal expectations and, from what he has heard, is easily on track for $100 billion of revenue, with… Full answer

  5. Chamath Palihapitiya says Anthropic will be one of the 10 megacorps and is doing the right things, but the valuation over the next three or four months has… Full answer

  6. Jason Calacanis is staying very long because he thinks AI use at big companies will spread from a small share of workers to all-day work with agents. Full answer

  7. David Friedberg says the biggest opportunity for AI is on the frontier, where people do work humans have never been able to do, not a small efficiency tweak… Full answer

  8. Chamath Palihapitiya says a website disclaimer that a company uses an open-source model would not change the product. Full answer

  9. David Friedberg says efforts to curb, restrict, or label open-source AI hand governments a tool for regulated monopolies, and he thinks those efforts limit… Full answer

  10. David Friedberg says the largest fundraise in human history just took place, and Anthropic raised $85 billion in a day. Full answer

  11. Jason Calacanis says Nvidia has shed $2 trillion in market cap over the last 30 days and is down 35%, and down 20% in the two weeks since Jensen Huang was… Full answer

  12. Chamath Palihapitiya says Jensen Huang was an exceptional founder who built the most important company in the most important industry, and also made mistakes… Full answer

  13. Chamath Palihapitiya reads the tape while they are recording: the S&P 500 is down 1.39%, the VIX is up 10.83%, Anthropic is up 18% from the IPO price, and… Full answer

Related notes

Original episode description
(0:00) Chamath's theory on 10 AI Megacorps that go "Dirt to Application" (3:27) Anthropic goes public, how companies are handling AI disruption (16:41) Bull/bear case for Anthropic and the market (36:41) White House weighs new open source disclosure rule for Chinese models (59:17) State of Nvidia: Tanking stock, talent crisis, legal issues, Jensen's future Follow the besties: https://x.com/chamath https://x.com/Jason https://x.com/DavidSacks https://x.com/friedberg Follow on X: https://x.com/theallinpod Follow on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/theallinpod Follow on TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@allin Follow on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/allinpod Intro Music Credit:

Speaker 1 0:00

All right, everybody, welcome back to the number one podcast in the world. Seven weeks running. That's right. We manifested it. We got a crazy docket. Zax couldn't make it this week. He's out. Chamath, you were a little on fire in the group chat. You have some theories. You

Expand full transcriptCollapse transcript

The episode notes above make this conversation easy to skim.

Speaker 1 0:00

All right, everybody, welcome back to the number one podcast in the world. Seven weeks running. That's right. We manifested it. We got a crazy docket. Zax couldn't make it this week. He's out. Chamath, you were a little on fire in the group chat. You have some theories. You have some thoughts. Please, the floor is yours. I have a theory. You have a theory.

Okay, just

Speaker 2 0:18

one, but it's a big one. Let's unpack it. I think that there are going to be nine to 10 megacorps that get built over the next decade because of AI. Yes. And I think that each megacorp is going to go from the application layer all the way down to the dirt. Now, why do I say this? I think the deal that Palo Alto Network said yesterday rips the Band-Aid off and I think was very smart.

What did they buy? They bought these brilliant guys that made open source models. And you would say, well, why is a security company, which should narrowly only be allowed to be in the security lane, why were they rewarded yesterday? The stock was up 8% or 9% at one point for buying an AI company. And Nikesh said it in the press release. He's like, this is us venturing outside of security, our first big venture.

And the market was like, thank God. And so what's happening? He's gonna own the model, right? Then he's gonna eventually own the dirt and the land and have the data centers vertically integrated. Then he's gonna go up the stack applications. What does Anthropic do it? And with all their money, they're already going down to the dirt and they're going up to the application stack.

OpenAI doing the same thing. SpaceX doing the same thing. They own one of the best apps in the game, Cursor. They own all the way down to the dirt. So what do you see taking shape? Meta. Meta owns all the way down to the dirt. all the way up to the app stack. So I think what AI is creating, essentially, is haves and have nots. The haves are the folks that have these critical assets that can be very tightly vertically integrated.

And I think that there's going to be 10 of these folks. And so you're going to have this really rich app ecosystem, a lot of open source models and some closed source models, And then you're gonna use a lot of distributed silicon. This I think is why Nvidia is trading down, is this realization that the over-earning era of Nvidia may be over.

This is independent of Jensen, where you just have a multitude of formats and ways in which you can actually compute what you need. And then you're gonna need this really important constraint, which is the land and the power. I think if you view it that way, Jason, you're going to see these eight, nine, 10 conglomerates, and now the market is betting who is a conglomerate and who is not.

That more than anything, I think, explains the flows over the last few weeks and probably the last year even. Interesting. Who's on the back heel that has to figure it out? If you are an established company with large amounts of free cash flow, and you're not going to go and enter the model game or the data center game, I think the market's going to punish you not by saying your stock is not good, but essentially by trading out of your stock to trade into those companies that are willing to take the risk.

Speaker 1 3:05

You need something that's more ambitious and Microsoft clearly is going to need to have a frontier

Speaker 2 3:11

model. It doesn't mean anything. What does it mean to make a product in a world where you have a trillion agents that you can spin up on demand to make anything you want? What is a product? I don't know what a product is. What is that?

Speaker 1 3:22

It is a valid question. If you can add new features at the rate Ant is doing, and speaking of mega corporations, Ant went public today, Anthropic. Freebird just upsized their IPO. Massive demand. They hit a $2 trillion valuation. Raised over $107 billion. Green shoe filled. 100 other green shoes could have been filled, apparently. That surpassed SpaceX's

Speaker 3 3:48

$85 billion valuation.

Speaker 1 3:50

And every other corporation seems to be off a bit today as people rotate into this. I guess retail really wanted to get a piece of the anthropic IPO with all the hype and people understand the product, I think. And this is going to be, I think, free bird, you might agree. We've been waiting to have some sunlight on a big portion of the AI trade, of the AI revolution, which was tokens and token sales and frontier models.

And now we're going to have all of that exposed to the light. And we're going to be able to figure out between SpaceX

and other cloud providers, Amazon Web Services, Azure. Now we have this missing piece. We're going to kind of, obviously we have NVIDIA to discuss as well today. We'll have NVIDIA's you know, chip sales, Cerebrus is chip sales. Now we understand like the complete picture, but are you, what's your take on this, the largest IPO of all time? And then maybe a little bit on Chamath's new theory, eight megacorps, 10 megacorps, and you gotta be in everything if you can't build software anymore because AI will build it instantly.

There's no value or mode around it. What's your take on his megacorps? dirt to services, I guess,

theory. Dirt to application.

Speaker 4 5:13

Yeah.

Speaker 1 5:13

Now you wouldn't include services in there because it seems like services in these

Speaker 2 5:16

for deploy engineers. You're bringing up something that's really important. This whole idea of software and services is for Luddites of the past.

And all these people, look, I think the problem when things change is

is some people find so much anxiety and change that what they need to do is they need to glom on to the past, they feel better about the past. And they use that to self soothe themselves, to pacify. What is a version of that in the public markets? I think it's this thing that they used to do to bucketize companies. And again, I will bring up that very famous memo about what you report when you can't report free cashflow.

Does anybody actually care whether you're a software company or a services company? You shouldn't. The people that care are morons. What you should care about is what is your free cash flow? Like if I could sell you a services business that had 99% gross margins and 70% free cash flow margins, would you buy it? Your answer would be yes, you'd buy it.

And you'd buy it over every product company that ever existed because it's just structurally financially better. And in a world where AI is going to be disrupting everything, what do you want to own? I would rather just own cash flow. And so I think what's going to happen, Jason, is people are going to stop caring about what kind of business you are from a business model perspective and care a lot more about what kind of business you are from a numerical perspective.

And if you have high gross margins and high free cash flow conversion, you will be rewarded. And if you don't, it won't matter what the hell you do. You're just going to get decimated.

Speaker 1 6:54

So the theory is the markets are going to be confused here, AI is shaking up the snow globe, existing businesses and verticals hard to for maybe people who are living in the past paradigm, they're trying to say this is a services business. This is a software business. This is an infrastructure business. Now it's all one giant thing. And SpaceX kind of drove this by putting all these pieces together.

And when they put Tesla and SpaceX together, now you've got a conglomerate. Google, obviously in conglomerate territory with Waymo on one side and their cloud business, their advertising business. And Amazon as well, I guess, has a conglomerate type feel to it. Microsoft maybe less so. And Apple, maybe less so, right? Because they kind of stay in their lanes.

Apple, consumer hardware, Microsoft, business software. You know, they got a little Xbox business over here that they've threatened to spin out. So what do you think of this theory, Freebird? Everybody's in every business line. And then all that matters is what comes out the end. You can play with the, you know, the knobs all you want. Maybe you make less profit on your hardware, more profit on your services.

You give the software for free. You make the money on the dirt and the infrastructure play, but you can kind of play with the knobs. Is that a SimAnt background? SimAnt. It's SimAnt, right?

Speaker 3 8:12

1991. Okay. I think there was an era when the internet kind of said to everyone, you've got to recast how your business operates, how you do commerce, how you create value. how you run your business, who's doing what, everything was digitized. And now we're kind of moving from this era of everything being digitized, which maybe it started in the 60s and the 70s with the computing revolution, but then all of that data got connected.

So everyone had to become a digitally connected business. And the era of AI is sort of like this digital intelligence business. And there's just a radical reinvention. And it's actually quite amazing how few businesses are actually spending money with Anthropic today, and how few people actively use, like AI tools every day. It's like, call it 1% of the population, which explains why people remain pretty pessimistic.

Because they haven't really understood it yet. But digital intelligence, I think really creates a

reinvention in every category of commerce.

I work in agriculture and, you know, every day we kind of observe ways that things have been done historically that make absolutely no sense from a first principles perspective in this era today. And it's almost like in every one of these categories, you know, when everyone kind of rethought every business category from the internet, it's like everyone has to rethink every business category from a digital intelligence basis.

you end up realizing pretty quickly that it's not just that the businesses are going to have to evolve, but the industries are going to get rewritten. It's no longer going to be this delineation of the way the supply chain works today. It's no longer going to be this delineation of where value sits in the value stack in any given industry, that suddenly one company can compress the value stack or one company can be multi-vertical.

Every single one of these industries perhaps don't even exist anymore, that there's some recasting that happens. So... Yeah, I mean, I think that's probably right. It's a wild, wild west right now.

Speaker 2 10:18

You know what's not going to be valuable? If you take your free cash flow and you spend it on buybacks.

Speaker 3 10:22

It says a lot about where you don't know where to invest. I mean, that's a good point about NVIDIA. That's exactly

Speaker 2 10:28

right. That's the tell. When you are like, I'm going to do a buyback, what you're basically saying is, I don't have a clue.

Speaker 1 10:34

You either don't have the high road and the hootspot to buy something, build something, which would be the other two categories to spend large amounts of money. Big criticism of Apple over the years. Tim Cook's stewardship of that firm was based largely on taking half the shares off the table. Massive buybacks, massive dividends. And if you look at NVIDIA, the CFO, as CFOs are wont to do, brought up.

stock buybacks. They authorized 150 billion in additional buybacks back in September before Jensen was ousted. Total buybacks, 235 billion. CFO said, now's the time. This is a top priority. I'm not pointing directly at Nvidia, but

Speaker 2 11:16

most of the EPS gains for many years in the stock market was because of this game. either because rates were low or because you had profitable companies, they took their free cash flow. And what did they do? They bought as much stock as they could. They fought back the dilution they were giving via stock grants to their employees. And they would increase the earnings per share, which is this game that everybody was playing.

And they were mostly rewarded for it. And they were creating a natural bid to their stock and the stock just trended up higher. And so you as a stockholder knew that if your company was going in to buy some percentage of the float every year, you were guaranteed mostly a five to 10% increase in the stock every year. And you can just kind of play this game.

That game is over. And the reason is what you said, Jason, because what it is, is a tell. And the tell is the following. I don't know what to buy. I don't know what to build. I don't know what to invest in, which is okay when disruption is low. But when disruption is high, you are going to be rewarded for acquisitions because that tells the existing investor, you are trying to defend the moat that you have and build new moats.

That is why when Nikesh does a $4.5 billion acquisition, the stock goes up. The market is voting. It doesn't matter what I think about it. What I saw was, wow, the market is saying, do more of that.

Speaker 1 12:46

Well, and there's also Freeberg, the game on the field. During certain administrations, We are anti-conglomerate. The feeling in America has been, and I hate that this always seems to go back to politics, but here we are, folks. The market... wasn't allowed to do big M&A. That was off the table during Biden. Now it's back on the table for Trump.

We got maybe six month window before it closes again, if people assume we're going to have Democrats in office in 2028. So you got to play the game on the field, as it were. The time to buy stock back, I think, is when your stock is severely under value, Chamath. Or when you find something, you have to look at what you're acquiring and say, is that company accretive enough? And can we grow it enough? Do we have a strategy post acquisition for it to grow versus buying our own stock? In other words, if I buy this business, me plus that business being accelerated by whatever we have, you know, is that better than buying our stuff? You

Speaker 2 13:49

said a word I don't agree with. Okay. But I do think that's how a lot of people think about it. And the word that you use, which I don't like is accretive. which is where the spreadsheet jockeys get into a room and try to figure out how it just adds to the value of the company today without thinking strategically, how does it add to the value of the company over some number of years? Because it puts you into business lines that you're not in today.

And I think you have to be in the latter category. And if you're beholden to an equity market that won't give you that permission, you're in a really complicated position because they're also not going to reward you for buybacks and they're not going to reward you for dividends. What are you to do with this money? Except invest your way out of it.

So this is the weird thing where the owners of these companies don't seem to get that there's a tsunami of disruption coming. And that they're going to have to position themselves defensively and offensively by having a full stack solution. That's the only solution. There's no way around it.

Speaker 1 14:48

And if you look historically at what's happened in our industry last 10 years, Apple has 10 over the last 10 years, Apple has 34% less shares. Alphabet, 12% less. Meta, 11%. And Meta's done some great acquisitions, but this is what people have chosen to do with their war chest. Now, the other option, which I kind of like, is building out infrastructure.

We talked about that. If you're Meta, you're Amazon, you're obviously Alphabet. Yeah, building out infrastructure and having the platform to create intelligence, that seems like a pretty wise investment as well. Yeah, Jamal, you think?

Speaker 2 15:25

Yeah, I mean, I think the problem where these guys will fail is I don't think that they understand what the next generation application stack really needs to look like. That needs to be acquired. And the reason is it's just much more likely that small groups of people bleed off of these big companies or bleed off the frontier labs and go and build the things that are the new thing.

They understand it better. And I think that that's okay. The point is you have to end up at the finish line with a solution. And I think it's actually simpler to say, I'm going to just acquire my way to it. And that's actually a safe harbor. Meaning if I was owning an equity and the CEO got on an investor call and said, you know what, guys, disruption is coming.

we're going to have 10 mega companies. I intend to be one of them. I'm going to acquire my way aggressively. I'm going to use my cashflow to make sure that we don't lose. I would own more of that stock than all the other stocks where everybody's just singing from the same hymn book from years ago. That's not what I want. I don't feel

Speaker 1 16:18

safe. Anybody who can see the pace of technology, Freeberg, understands now is the time to take some swings and What's your take on the anthropic IPO and the future of this company? 80 billion in revenue, 100 billion, they're obviously, the percentage growth is going to slow down. But if we're at 2 trillion, now they're trading 20 times the top line.

Is this company going to just spend a couple years going sideways as it fills in that valuation? And are you long short it? I know you didn't like that question last week, but I think people want to know from us. Are we bullish or bearish or kind of moderate on the future of Ant after the IPO today? Obviously, it's great that they got out, especially in the turmoil going on now.

So points to them for getting out the door. I think that was a wise move. But what's your take on the company itself now, Freebird?

Speaker 3 17:11

It's been growing beyond their expectations internally from what I've heard from people. So it seems like they're easily on track for getting to $100 billion of revenue. And I think they've got a lot of runway. We talked about them being probably less than 1% market penetrated in terms of their addressable users that could spend over 100 grand a year.

So lots of runway. They definitely have the best enterprise product out there. better than Google and better than OpenAI. And at this point, I think Google's done four model releases in the last few weeks. A lot of people are murmuring that Google seems to have hit the RSI runaway kind of loop. If Google's done it, then I think it's likely that Anthropic is there as well.

And it's a matter of time. There's certainly a lot of hesitation around the safety concerns in this moment in time. So there's probably a lot more being held back than people realize. The models are probably advancing at a pace that is faster than the human evaluation that can be done to ensure its safety. So, you know, Google's indication, I think, would be positive for Anthropic having also achieved some whatever the definition is of RSI, which means that the models improve themselves, they get continuously better, and you end up on this effectively kind of exponential curve on

one way to think about this is intelligence per dollar. So if you've got this massively scaling units of intelligence per dollar spent underway, this kind of system that kind of improves itself and delivers more, certainly sky's the limit. The economy is the limit for a company like this. And I think, like I mentioned last week, I heard they did a great job in the roadshow of convincing investors that there is almost this like true, natural monopolistic advantage inherent in the business that the RSI and the cost as that results, meaning that the cost per unit of intelligence goes down dramatically, makes it an insurmountable moat that other people can't catch up to.

The biggest risk is open source. So the argument might be that, you know, maybe open source is a risk that could eat some part of the business, but I don't think it's going to eat the whole business because at the end of the day, if they're going to have the greatest intelligence per unit of dollars spent for the advanced applications, they're always going to be the choice.

So it'll probably be between them, open AI, Google at this point is sort of the race. The question really is how much excess demand was there that didn't get met in the order books as they got filled out. And how many of the $100 billion of share purchases that have happened today are folks that would sell in a short period of time versus want to be long-term holders? And let's call it 50%.

So you probably got $50 billion of true float against probably some multiple of $100 billion of demand at the current price. And so the question is, there's obviously some elasticity to that pricing. As it moves up, the demand will go down. And the market will tell us where that limit is. But given the growth rate, given the potential, there's an amazing story to be told here that if you're willing to buy the stock and own it for five plus years, you could hold a multi-bagger from here at this entry point.

And that's true for them. It's true for SpaceX. It's true for potentially Google, even at this moment. So there's a lot of upside as the economy gets rewritten around AI.

Speaker 1 20:37

Jamath, when you see it go public at $2 trillion, roughly 30 times their run rate, what's your take on the future of this company specifically? You heard Freeberg talk about, well, On one side of the ledger, you do have open source. And we're going to talk about the administration or a contingent of the administration reportedly trying to stop open source and tar and signal who is using open source.

Pretty dark stuff. We'll get into it. But just as we hit day one on Thursday, we tape you listen on Friday. What's your take here on the future of this company? Do you believe it's going to beat the markets? Do you believe it's a juggernaut? Do you believe it's unstoppable? Or do you believe it, hey, maybe we might be sitting here in three or four years and it's still trying to fill in this valuation?

Speaker 2 21:23

I think it's definitely going to be one of these 10 megacorps. They're doing all the right things. My biggest risk for that business, I think they've de-risked now, which is balance sheet and having enough money. So I don't know about the valuation per se. If you look at it, it's had the exact opposite trading behavior of SpaceX, which doesn't mean anything meaning but the day one behavior is the exact opposite where SpaceX traded up, and then kind of came off at the late day, this one kind of started up already, and then has been coming down.

So on a day one behavior, who knows, it's hard to intuit. So it is a great business. It's a great long term business.

They're doing all the right things, meaning they're going dirt all the way up to application. All that makes sense. But I think the problem is that the valuation of Anthropic over the next three or four months has mostly nothing to do with Anthropic. If you look at other businesses that are making gobs of money NVIDIA is a perfect example.

We've never seen a quarter like this ever, and the stock is down. And it's down meaningfully from the earnings date. Why is that? The market, when I look at this, I could change my mind, but right now what it looks like is it's trying to will itself to go up.

And the problem with that is that inflation is sticky. All of these external conditions are not resolved, including the war. I think people on balance feel skittish. They feel like this has run for a while. And I think the balance of trade is to de-risk, not to add more risk. So I think you're going to have all kinds of pockets of opportunities to buy stuff much cheaper.

And then on top of that, what you're seeing, Jason, is this very weird behavior where there is just these crazy acute moments, just as we are taping. AMD is down 10 or 12% because somebody put out a short report that they were selling chips to China. I don't know if that's true or not, but 10, 12% trade in a trillion dollar company is ginormous vol.

So I guess what I do know is that the 10-year unfortunately keeps ticking up. That's bad for equities. Vol is elevated. That's bad for equities.

And inflation is sticky. That's bad for equities. To the extent Kevin Warsh wanted to cut, I don't think he's got much room. And if anything, he's going to hike. That's bad for equities.

There's a new sheriff in town in the Senate and in Congress that creates uncertainty. That's bad for equities. So the wall of worry now is bonkers. Yeah. Maybe you can't be short. I don't know. Cause like things could still rip in your face. but it's hard to justify how you get mega long here, what you're aiming for. What is the setup where the S&P goes to 8,000 from here versus 6,500? I'll take a shot at it.

I don't understand it.

Speaker 1 24:31

I got,

Speaker 2 24:31

I'll take a shot at it because I'm

Speaker 1 24:32

super long. Yeah. And I think this is the, I think we're bouncing along the bottom independent of like a crazy black swan type of that COVID, et cetera. But that wall of worry that you very accurately described, you got rates you got the debt and you got inflation you got wars and you got uh political uh turnover And the people coming in hate AI, big tech, capitalism, they're going to be in the breakup big tech, we can be having a conversation in two or three years about, you know, let's say you're the if Chamath's thesis is correct, we're going into the mega corp, you know, AOC, and Bernie Sanders, and that constituent might say, Yeah, we're not going to allow that.

And we're going to go the opposite direction, we're gonna make you break up these companies. But the bull case that I see is We have only 10 or 20% of workers at the major companies using this technology. I invest in 100 startups a year. I see how they use it. They use it all day long. They're using it, the average worker, five, six, seven hours a day.

In other words, they're working with AI more than they're working with humans. What startups do is what the big companies eventually do. It takes two or three years. Startups embrace the cloud and we work because it's more efficient. Then sure enough, the big companies will do that. So I'm watching that game on the field. I think we're going to see the number of people in the organizations use it.

You know, obviously go five, six, seven X because they're Very small number of people in organizations using it. But more importantly, they're going to go from using it for minutes a day or maybe an hour to using it for six, seven, eight hours a day. That's going to be the primary use case at work, especially in corporate America. You're going to be working with agents and you're going to be coordinating 10 virtual workers.

That is the obvious thing that's going to happen. How do I know it's obvious? I see it inside my venture capital firm. I see it in my media company. I see it in 600 startups I've invested in. It's obvious. What that means is at least 500 times the token usage is what's going to happen. Now, where do those tokens come from becomes the question.

Does it come from Anthropic? Does it come from SpaceX, open source, AWS? And I think the answer is all of those. So what we're going to be sitting here in three or four years, people are going to look at this moment in time, very similar to the dotcom era, where people said, I think this whole thing got overhyped. It's a bubble. People lost their objectivity for what's actually going on inside of corporate America and then how the individuals are using it.

Individuals, once they start using bot technology, once they understand how to make loops and to get the best out of these things, they don't stop. They don't stop. And their productivity goes through the roof, like 10x, 20x. I

Speaker 2 27:19

don't understand how you can connect that with why stocks are bottomed.

Speaker 1 27:24

Well, the bottoming of the stocks, I think, is... Rates, inflation, the overall economy being this headwind and the political turmoil. People think this thing is overheated. I think it's underappreciated. That's just my belief. I think if you look at products, management, and market, the market here is going to go 500x. The demand for this product is like a 500x lift.

And then the management of these companies, putting aside Jensen getting ousted, is just incredible. Like the products these teams are making are extraordinary. The headwind is regulation, banning it, breaking up companies. And those are all real possibilities. But you're not at the product velocity now and the extent that people are embracing this technology, Chamath, I've never seen in my career.

And I've watched four decades of this now. You've convinced me and I agree with you that

Speaker 2 28:20

usage is mediocre and hasn't even approached what the full capability is. You've convinced me of that, but you have not convinced me why the stock market has bought it. Like I said, I think that it's more likely that the 10 year is at five and a half or 6% than it is at four and a half percent that just has a mathematical implication to all equities.

Speaker 1 28:40

I like the pushback. Imagine you're running a company You've got 200 knowledge workers working there, and they're currently spending on a $20 a month plan to a $200 a month plan. They become five times more effective at their job, 10 times more effective at the job. And they say, may I go from the $200 plan to the $800 plan? And you say, absolutely.

I have people coming to me in my own organization where I'm watching. You're saying revenue is going to go up 50x in

Speaker 2 29:07

this company?

Speaker 1 29:08

5x to 50? From whom? you will be able to create more products and services and deliver them at a higher- What product? Revenue and earnings per

Speaker 2 29:19

employee. Virtual products, you're saying, not physical products, because physical products still have

Speaker 1 29:23

input costs and those input costs are going up. So I'm talking about software services, knowledge work, all of that. is going to go from 500,000 to a million dollars an employee, to three to 5 million, maybe even $10 million per employee. And if you look at companies like Microsoft, they were at I think, 900,000 an employee, and now they're trending towards 2 million per employee, that trend is going to happen every three years, you're going to see the amount of revenue per employee double, which means if the revenue per employee doubles that efficiency level, That means you don't care if they spend 10x on software because the software was only 10k of or 5k of their

overall cost, maybe 5k or their overall cost a year. So if it goes to 25k, you don't care. You're like, great. You're a superhero inside this organization. I hope

Speaker 2 30:12

you're right. But I think the market is in a show me state. Sure. You have to prove it. I don't think they buy that.

Speaker 1 30:17

You have to have cojones to be buying NVIDIA right now at 150, 160. I did.

You got to have cojones right now if you want to buy some of these stocks, I think. Why do you say it's cojones? These

Speaker 2 30:27

are just mathematical risk-adjusted EV decisions. It's not about like some courageous chest pumping.

Speaker 1 30:33

No, I do think you have to have conviction because you have to believe, and I don't think it's a mathematical certainty that it goes 500x in consumption. That's my belief based on what I see. But I think a lot of people are doing the mathematical calculation, just saying it's impossible to get there because they don't see... just how transformative the technology is.

That's what I'm looking at. How transformative is this? How much will people spend on it? I think it's being greatly underestimated. Friedberg, you've been listening to this conversation. You have any input here on the bull bear case here? for the deployment of the technology? And what are you seeing inside of Ohalo? Are you seeing people 10X their usage of the technology? And are you seeing the output of that? No, that's not the question.

Of course the output. Is revenue up 10X? That was the second part. Are you seeing a multitude of consumption of tokens and a multitude of efficiency and revenue? Or are you predicting that? Because it does take some investment to get to there.

Speaker 3 31:30

I'll repeat what I've said in the past, which is I think the biggest opportunity for AI is on the frontier. That is where basically businesses and people can do things that humans and businesses have never been able to do before. And that means crafting solutions to really difficult engineering problems, to really difficult scientific problems, to previously untractable problems.

And that's where I think that the frontier gets expanded by 100x or 1000x.

versus AI being some like iteration on existing business processes to save money and make things more efficient, which is where people natively go, because most people don't work on the frontier and they're not kind of pushing the envelope on what's possible. So their mind is always about, well, how does this change my job? And then you immediately get fearful about your job getting recast.

And the truth is that's not the typical use case. The typical use case where we spend time and spend tokens is doing things that we've never done before, figuring out how to solve those really tough problems, how to do it quickly, how to do it efficiently. And that means humans generally can expand our frontiers, our horizons. That's what I kind of see.

And I still believe that. And I do think that there's this, we all get caught up so much in the kind of reinvention of existing businesses and cost savings and nonsense.

The return on dollars spent on tokens or whatever is some small number when you're doing it to produce the same stuff versus it being a much bigger number if you use it to produce things that humans have never produced before, like some new cancer drug or some new material science. And so I don't think that's really where people spend time and money or will as the capabilities are realized.

Speaker 2 33:18

Yeah, there's two things there. That's a really smart way of saying it. That's absolutely true. You throw tokens at the existing shit. You're just going to, what can you ROI? You know, 50%, 60% to your point. You

Speaker 1 33:28

might as well throw that new shit. There's certainly incremental improvement. I think you stated it well there, Freeberg. You can incrementally improve any job.

Speaker 3 33:35

Which is also why the job loss narrative is bullshit. It's also why the, you know, everyone's going to end up on welfare is bullshit. It's also like we need the government to step in and provide UBI is bullshit. Because like with any other kind of frontier moment in human history, it's the new jobs, the new industries get created before the old ones are irrelevant.

And therefore there's a bridge. And the demand and the pull forward that happens, meaning like, why did everyone, you know, at one point, San Francisco was the second most populous city in the United States because everyone pulled forward to the frontier to the gold rush that was happening during that small number of years when that happened.

And so like everyone got on the train and they all went out there because there's so much more value to be realized if you're in San Francisco than if you're working in a factory on the East Coast. And so that is why everyone kind of jumped forward. San Francisco kind of, I think, has historically been this really interesting sort of place where technology takes leaps forward.

So people do come out here a lot, as we know, as we've all experienced many times. Tourist

Speaker 1 34:37

season, we call it.

Speaker 3 34:39

Yeah, the boom and bust moments here in San Francisco. Everyone rushes to the next kind of frontier, the next wave. And that happens before the old wave gets recast and shut down. It's why we don't see rising unemployment because there's so much new stuff happening so quickly that it is happening before because it's such a more attractive way to put time and money and people and dollars is in the new stuff before you go and try and reinvent the old stuff.

I'd rather like go and invent a cure to cancer and go after a trillion dollar market to put a capitalist hat on this thing at the same time than to go and figure out how to optimize the supply chain of some manufacturing business at a factory in the East Coast. And as a result, there's much more demand for jobs, for capital in that new frontier than there is loss of jobs in the old world.

And so I think we've got it all pretty wrong or the media has this narrative quite wrong. And I think that's why we haven't seen the job apocalypse. It's why we don't see everyone rushing for UBI. Now, there is still a K-shaped economy problem in the sense that not everyone is coming along and benefiting and riding that frontier wave. And that is a more kind of fundamental disjointedness that's happening in this moment that may actually prevent that frontier from emerging because of the negative backlash associated with what's happening, because people see that frontier happening, they're not participating, they're not a part of it, they're not in it, and so.

Speaker 1 36:07

And the backlash is such a, if you want me to build on

Speaker 3 36:10

this. To everyone's view, it's just, I'd rather see it shut down if I'm not in it.

Speaker 1 36:14

All right. I want to go to the backlash here, Chamath. We have two backlashes now, both emerging from the two political parties we're stuck with here in America. On the left, we talked about anti-data center, which I think will soon be anti-self-driving and anti-capitalism, wealth tax. You put that all in one bucket. Now, on the right, we're having And obviously, they have concerns, America First, on jobs and immigration.

But here's a new one. White House is reportedly discussing a new open source disclosure rule to name and shame people using open source models. According to Reuters, companies could soon be forced to disclose on their websites if they're using Chinese open source AI models. No indication of how that would occur, who's driving it. Apparently, Treasury Department, Besant, who it seems is emerging as the leader of the China Hawk Group.

This is all happening in real time, this civil war inside the White House. And then you have the White House OSTP, Michael Krasteos, who I think you interviewed, yeah, Freeberg? I don't know if you did it with Chamath. Reuters also reports that more people in D.C. are now calling for a tougher stance on China, giving the China hawks much more influence.

Obviously, on the other side, you got a Lutnik and Trump himself. This year, Airbnb, DoorDash and Cursor have all received letters from members of the House Select Committee on China. Because of their use of open models, Airbnb is saying, well, yeah, we use some open source models for our customer support. Breaking news, Chamath, I also am using a MacBook Pro, so I don't know if this podcast needs to have a label on it that we're producing it with Chinese hardware.

Nothing has been decided in this, but it does seem like a wider crackdown. What are your thoughts on why now? Why now? Why is this leaking now? Jensen being ousted, Anthropic going public, the D-Cell movement. Is this all coordinated or is it all just a very interesting amount of timing?

Speaker 2 38:21

Can I answer your first question, which is? Sure. What will it do if you put a disclaimer on your website that you use an open source model? Nothing. It'll mean that you're not retarded. So it's the not retarded logo. Got it. Think about what the market wants. What does the market want? The market wants you to be smart. It wants you to be budget friendly.

It wants you to be ROI oriented. It wants you to own your own technology. It does not want you to leak your alpha. Right? AI sovereignty is what we bundled that under here on the pot. That's what they want. Otherwise, why would they want to own your stock? Because what is the alternative? For you to say, I don't really care about cost. I'll just take whatever model is available to me.

I'll feed them all the traces and spans. They may learn how to compete against me by me using their own product. They tell me they're not going to do it because of zero data retention policies. I trust them. It is what it is. The market will think you're an idiot. And why will they think you're an idiot? Because you would actually be an idiot.

You would demonstrate that you have such a lack of technical awareness, that there's nobody even half technical on your team, that you have an inability to even recruit a consultant to help you explain what happens. Call Alex Karp. He'll send all kinds of FTEs, brilliant engineers, to tell you what the risks are. And then you can make a decision.

So if the decision is, disclaim a thing that nobody's going to see on your website, or go out of business,

Speaker 1 39:50

I would disclaim the thing, not go out of business. You could do a pair trade, one of your favorite things, of the companies that are smart and dumb. So

Speaker 2 39:57

maybe what this actually says is, do the disclaimer. Who cares? What it really speaks to is, I think Washington needs some extremely technical people on the inside that explains the actual technical implications of some of these things. I think that the thing that was floated there was a trial balloon. And I think if you go through the series of explanations of what it means and doesn't mean to use this stuff, you would come to the conclusion, well, wait a minute, to not say that you'd be using cheaper open source alternatives to retain your edge is more destructive to American companies.

Is that what we actually want? The opposite disclaimer, or that you don't use a model at all? So I just think like these things aren't

Speaker 1 40:41

well understood. Freeberg, if you look at open sources, this shows a fundamental misunderstanding of how open source works. You're not buying it from the Chinese. It's on GitHub. It's on a website. You take it, you fork it, you put it on your own servers, you use it, you control it. There's no back doors. And if there were, you would immediately have a thousand AIs pointing at the back door in it.

It's kind of ridiculous. If it was, hey, I'm using Huawei technology. Yeah, perhaps you could say, hey, this person's using something, you know, it's hardware based. But what were your thoughts on this very strange leak and why it's leaking now and why it's floated and why they're sending this to Airbnb? This seems like complete, utter incompetence on whoever created this concept.

What did they send to Airbnb? Earlier in the year, they sent a letter. It's coming out now in this Reuters report that this letter was sent. DoorDash got one and Cursor got one. So these are letters from the House Select Committee on China for American companies using open source models that originate in China. I would think DeepSeek and GLM 5.2, you know, etc.

Speaker 3 41:47

Yeah, I think this continues to be the path of tyranny. And any effort to try and curb open source, restrict open source, label open source, and give the government the tools to create effectively regulated monopolies through the anti-open source efforts that are being undertaken, I think is going to both limit human prosperity, limit individual liberty, create an Orwellian state, and I think fundamentally violates freedoms of speech.

And I don't think that the origin of open source software should matter. Some people might disagree. But when you download open weight, open source

model from a repository, which is means a website where these things are stored, and anyone can get a copy of them.

You can then use it on your own server, your own computer, run it in the background, you can rewrite it, you can reuse it. And this was the basis of the Apache foundations. tool that created open source servers that allowed us to have the open internet, the open browsers with the Mozilla Foundation and Firefox so that Netscape and Microsoft couldn't restrict people's access to the internet.

And we had an open source free version that people then ended up making many different forks or many different versions of. And what Google did with Android, where they created open source operating software for mobile phones, and found hardware companies that would make it the de facto installed software, so that 70% of phones in the world today have unfettered access to the internet.

Whereas before with closed source software, the companies were going to try and control what apps you could put on your phone, what websites you could access, everything was monitored, everything was controlled. We're now facing the same decision point in open source AI as we did with all of those other prior technologies and open source needs to be allowed and frankly encouraged to proliferate because the absence of that means that you're going to have tyrannical groups of Ultimately, they become tyrannical, they don't intend to be tyrannical.

But every group that has the power to control what people see, what they're allowed to do, what they're allowed to access, how they're allowed to use things, what those specific weights are on, quote, unquote, facts of history, unquote, unquote, proven science, unquote, unquote, the truth. that is where people become tyrannical, because they have an opinion where they think they're right.

And if they have the power, they will act on that opinion. And it will ultimately give them tyrannical force over a broader population. That's what will happen if we limit the proliferation of open source software in AI. And I've said it before, I'll say it again, ultimately, you can regulate, you can restrict, you can control, you can litigate, you can criminally penalize people for the outputs of what they use software to do.

But to limit software to label software to make it a point of restriction and control creates a regulated monopoly for the closed source products that are out there, that ultimately, if aligned with certain government agencies, gives those government agencies and those individual corporations power and control over you, the individual, what you're allowed to do, what you're not allowed to do in every business on earth, no longer operates freely.

None of us should want that. I don't care what your political affiliation is.

Speaker 2 45:22

Would you support a bunch of these cash-rich public companies now

standing up a bunch of open source model initiatives inside of their companies? Would you view

Speaker 3 45:33

that? 100%, yeah. Yeah, it's great. And I think Meta should, I think it's the play for Meta. Meta's already doing it. Google's already doing it. But they're not doing it with Frontier yet. They're doing it with the previous

Speaker 2 45:43

ones. Meta's open source models are nerfed. They've been nerfed for a while. They're not good.

Speaker 3 45:47

And by the way, I think that one point to note, the idea that you can, quote, label something Chinese. So in an internet that's anonymous, where people can post on Hugging Face a new open source model, the origin of that model may not need to be defined. So someone could just post a new model on Hugging Face We all see it. It's the best open source model ever.

And it doesn't say what, quote, country it comes from. It was trained somewhere. It was built somewhere. Some set of engineers wrote this thing, posted it, and now it's available to the world. What do you do? How do you classify that? Why does the country of origin matter as much when it comes to open weight, open source, when anyone, because it's open weight, open source nature of it, you can go in.

It's a fundamental misunderstanding.

Speaker 1 46:31

Yeah, these people don't understand

Speaker 3 46:33

how it works. They can

Speaker 1 46:34

go in and

Speaker 3 46:34

they can test it. Anyone can look at it, you can see there's no there's no runtime software in there. Just to be really clear about this. Open source open weight is not a runtime application. You don't download it and run it on your computer. you have to have an environment in which you're running those open source, open weights against. So this isn't some like, there's some hidden tricks or tools inside of that software that can screw your computer over and hack you and take over.

That's not the way this works. Technologically, people I think are deficient in that understanding. And then they're trying to make rules and regs around like, well, you don't know what the Chinese are doing. It's like, well, actually we do. We fundamentally can see in an open source open rate model, you see

Speaker 1 47:15

everything. Every commit's right

Speaker 3 47:16

there. It is not an executable. It is a set of data. It is a piece of data, a chunk of data, a CSV file with a bunch of stuff in it. That's all it is. And you are deciding how you will then take that data and you will use it in making your own applications and your own software. And you as a builder of software can decide how you're going to use that.

So in fact, this misunderstanding where people say, well, we don't really know is incorrect. We do know. And you can look and you can adjudicate and you can audit and you can test and you can do all the things you want to do for safety and security screening. In fact, everyone faces liability if they don't. Because if you then take something that does something that doesn't work, your product's going to suck.

You're going to break the law. There's all sorts of bad things that could happen. It's your job to adjudicate whether the open source software does its job. That's your job. And that's the way open source works. So to have the government come in and suddenly try and create their genius patch, their bandaid idea of telling people to label stuff and not label stuff is as idiotic as I would expect it to be given the lack of engineering competence in the United States Congress.

And that's not political, by the way, that's just fact.

Speaker 1 48:21

Well, I mean, there is something political going on here, Chamath. If you look at when Jensen was on, or we were at Jensen's conference, and you look at the discussion we had, and we were talking about Nemotron, and then he started buying some open source assets, we now have emerging a series of events of the Chinese hawks and maybe the open source pro open source movement, all of this is happening in the same time period.

There are no coincidences is I think, a rubric many of us go by, I certainly do. I don't believe this is all a bunch of random coincidences. It's pretty clear Jensen was going to become the open source champion, his models, you mentioned conglomerates from, you know, dirt to the application layer and beyond. He was building that. He was building that.

He was suddenly deposed. Then you have this, we're going to name and shame Airbnb and DoorDash for using open source. Okay, that's happening at the same time. And Ant is going public at the same time. It feels like there is a giant civil war going on and a global conflict over open source versus frontier models. And who is the champion for them?

Speaker 2 49:37

I don't think it's that nuanced. I think it's more about power, and I think it's about control, and I think it's about ideology.

Speaker 1 49:43

Okay. Unpack. Yeah.

Speaker 2 49:44

I think the ideology is whether you believe that this advantages the Chinese or not.

And I think that there's a strong case to be made that it does, but there's a strong case to be made that it doesn't. And I think depending on how ideologically grounded you are in neoconservatism, you will bend in one way or the other. I think the reality is that there are things that in hindsight, again, hindsight's 2020,

that could have been done to create escape velocity for open source. It's really a shame when you look back on it. With all the money that the domestic American companies have, Why did we not find a way to spend some of that money to get real escape velocity for a true American open source alternative? I think that's an important question worth asking.

Why are the only open source alternatives Chinese that are any good? Why? I

Speaker 1 50:43

think it might be, if you look at the talent, the talent had two really good options and a third and fourth. Work on proprietary models and make hundreds of millions of dollars or billions of dollars personally for that talent. So the talent went to OpenAI, They left Google, which was not paying attention to AI, maybe to the extent they should have.

And then you have these two major money grabs opportunity and all the talent flow to them and then obviously to X. But that's not true.

Speaker 2 51:13

That's not true because there are some really talented people at Meta. There's some really talented people. I'll tell you why. At Google, there's some really talented people in NVIDIA. The question is, why couldn't we spend 50 or 100 billion dollars of the trillion dollars of cash that we've spent? Tragedy. And

Speaker 1 51:26

not had a really good... Alternative. Freebrook, why? Too much money to be made in the frontier models. It was the incentive. Show me the incentive. I'll show you the outcome.

Speaker 3 51:35

It's not just money to be made. It's capital to be raised. I think it was a lot easier over the last couple of years to raise capital as a private frontier model company than go out and say, I'm going to build an open source AI company. You're not going to be able to attract. So when you're like, hey, I'm going to build a model, you want to be a frontier lab.

You get a bunch of great geniuses together and you're like, let's go build a new frontier lab. your two business plans are open source, how are we going to make money? I don't know, we'll figure it out later. For the good of humanity, I don't know, or closed source, and we'll make money on the standard business model, the venture money, you're saying the VCs

Speaker 2 52:11

perverted the incentives.

Speaker 3 52:12

Yeah, capitalists in general, right. So capitalists in general created the system, where you could plow lots of money, whereas the for the Chinese, it's actually a very different game theory, because for the Chinese, It's how do we disrupt American capitalism? How do we disrupt the American AI ecosystem? How do we create an alternative to close source where America controls the world, blah, blah, blah.

So for the Chinese, it's very rational for them to proliferate open wave model.

Speaker 2 52:37

Wait, hold on a second. But why isn't that the same game theory if you're Nvidia or Facebook or Amazon in the sense that

Speaker 3 52:46

you're a little bit behind? I think you're exactly right. And I think we've been on the precipice of that being the case. And I think it all got blown up in the last week.

Speaker 1 52:52

Yeah, that's why NVIDIA bought all of these open source resources. So that actually tracks with your original theory. I think these guys were all

Speaker 3 53:00

about... Hold on, let me

Speaker 1 53:02

finish. When you're behind, you go open source to try to kill the existing... codified solution. That's what Android did to iOS. And now that's what NVIDIA was doing. They literally bought all those open source products. Yeah, but

Speaker 2 53:15

none of those things were about models themselves. They're about hosting models. That's all fine and good. But you could have given more compute to Nemotron. Which he was doing. He was starting that process. If you look at the checkpoints on Nemotron, they're unfortunately behind. So for whatever reason, whether it was compute constrained or talent constrained, the models are good, but they're not great.

And the GLM models and the other Chinese variants are... better than good, also still not great. And obviously the frontier ones are great. My question is that boundary condition that both of you just talked about was true a year ago. It was true a year before that. Why wasn't the money spent then? Why didn't we score? If we meaning if I was too much money

Speaker 3 53:53

made with like, there's just too much capital. Look, I mean, look what happened today. Today, the largest fundraise in human history just took place. Anthropic in a day raised $85 billion.

Speaker 2 54:04

I know for a private company, I'm saying follow the money. If I was running AI at Meta, I would say, you know what I'm going to do? I'm going to scorch the earth right now. Two years ago, I would have said this. If I'm going to spend a billion dollars on Andrew Tulloch and a billion- I think they did, dude. Yeah, they tried. They tried.

Speaker 3 54:18

I think you're right. And I think they did. And I think that they just didn't get there. Right.

Speaker 1 54:22

And Nvidia's

Speaker 3 54:23

in the process- It's just that simple.

Speaker 1 54:25

The models suck? Well, no, they're getting there. It takes time. They're two years behind. You're explaining the theory perfectly, but not getting to the conclusion. Yes, people realized they were behind and there was an opportunity there. And then Jensen bought. And this might've been his downfall. He bought Hugging Face and he bought Poolside.

He spent 20 billion on those two companies. So he said, yes, we're going to double down, triple down on this. And Meta and Zuck said, yes, we're going to do it as well. Now you said they were nerfed. Yeah. Okay. So they didn't get it done, but the intentionality was there and it's in process. And I believe that's at the core of why Jensen was- Do you have a different

Speaker 3 54:59

theory to them off?

Speaker 1 55:00

I kind of have like a- like a working version of one. Well, let's workshop it. Go ahead. That's why we're here. Workshop it. I, no mistakes here. No, no bad ideas.

Speaker 2 55:09

I'm really at a loss because if it were me, I would have stuck a, again, hindsight's 2020. So this is where like, you know, We did talk about this, but if I was an entrant at that scale with that balance sheet two years ago and I was far behind, it made a lot of sense to commoditize the model layer. If you were a non-model native company, right? You make the money in the apps, you make the money in the chips, you make the money in the LPS, you don't need to make money at the model.

That seems obvious. So you pay a bunch of money and you try to spin a model and what do you learn? It's much, much harder than you think. And I guess I still struggle with, isn't it just a money and a recruiting problems? Because what you guys are saying is, VCs created incentive to come and say, we're going to build a closed frontier model, or we're going to build an app company.

And you could raise lots of money. So I don't know, I'm still like, the only theory I had was they took the eye off the ball. And they just got distracted with, hold on, just let me finish. they just got distracted with all this other bullshit.

Speaker 1 56:14

And it's like, just finish your breakfast. You're correct that in hindsight, and if you were a great strategist, you would just carved out $25 billion and made an open source project at Microsoft at Google, or Apple, whoever's behind meta, and just make that your way to be make that your strategy for open source. I think two companies were exactly pursuing that Zuck and Jensen.

Now, if you look, though, at the money and the incentives, what is the average person, Freeberg? What is the average person going to work at OpenAI, who's a computer scientist, or going to work at Anthropic? What is their pay package like? These people got offered pay packages. I was talking to somebody whose kid out of school got offered $10 million a year in equity at Claude over four years.

This is a really good computer science undergraduate who got a $40 million package. Like this has never existed in the history of our industry. And then remember that time when Zuck was trying to buy somebody for a billion dollar pay package? Remember he went crazy?

Speaker 2 57:21

Yeah.

Speaker 1 57:22

So they kind of jumped the fence in that environment. Freeberg's exactly right. How does an open source company compete? They don't have the dollars. They don't have the market cap to buy all that talent. But I think now we're probably going to see

MuseSpark, Nemotron, and then Reflections Beam. Those three are just behind Kimi, DeepSeek, GLM53, and then you got this weird mistral out in France, which is kind of interesting.

Speaker 2 57:48

The French one is

Speaker 1 57:49

right between the three trailing US ones and the three leading Chinese ones. We'll sit here in a year, and the US ones will be somewhere in between DeepSeek and Kimi. Let me give you a different theory.

Speaker 2 58:00

It could happen now, and... It could happen now because you're seeing almost this schism where these leading edge folks are kind of splintering. You guys saw that there was this thing written called misanthropic, right? Was that like a missive with like a bunch of signatories? And it was a bunch of folks that are sort of like

EA people that had this schism. There could be a version of this where really smart folks now at these model companies are who have made a lot of money now start to leave. And they're like, you know, it's probably important to have some open source alternatives. And so maybe they go and work on this stuff in a more nonprofit way. because they have that money and they have this predilection already to being a little bit less capitalist.

So that could happen.

Speaker 1 58:50

No, I think it's a very interesting insight. And obviously, you might have many people in the audience probably saw the New York Times story here that had Dostoevsky's

early investments in anthropic and open AI, a big profile in him being uneasy about all this stuff. And I do think it's a non-zero chance a lot of these people will get together and build the alternative to what the proprietary models are putting out there. Let's end on NVIDIA They've shed $2 trillion in market cap in the last 30 days, down 35%.

Two weeks since Jensen got shivved, it's down 20%. CFO and acting CEO Colette Kress didn't exactly inspire confidence during her first earnings call, but the earnings call was extraordinary. NVIDIA beat the top and bottom line. Revenue and net profit both doubled. Yes, doubled. On already absurdly large numbers to $116 billion and $65 billion, respectively.

Let that sink in. $65 billion in profit. Most companies trading in the stock market are not worth what NVIDIA just made in profits this quarter. Stock, even after all that, dropped. Internet's having a field day with this. Here's your viral moment of Cress on Mad Money with Jim Cramer.

Speaker 4 1:00:11

Jensen resigned from his position with NVIDIA and the board accepted his resignation. The board has determined that they will not reinstate Jensen. And that is our statement and what the board has decided to do.

Speaker 1 1:00:30

Internet obviously having a field day with this. Everybody is very pro Jensen, it seems, except for the board of this company. And no more splashy cashy is one of the messages here. Crest said they're going to be more disciplined and selective, quote, more disciplined and selective on new Neo cloud financing. Obviously, Jensen loved to invest in startups and companies that were building the future.

So the bank of Jensen is closed. And she ended the H200 sales to China. H200 is obviously a more powerful version of the flagship H100. NVIDIA is allowed to sell H200s to China. Commerce approved those for sale in January. I know this is all very complicated, folks. But this is an elective move, according to the news. She's just saying, you know what, we don't want anything to do with this anymore.

The most powerful GPUs, Rubin and Blackwell, are obviously banned from being sold to China. And the board repeatedly is saying Jensen cannot come back. Jensen said he would humbly like to come back. And there seems to be a group of people mounting his comeback to a certain extent. We'll see. In related news, NVIDIA is facing mounting legal issues.

You predicted this. Chamath, SEC probe, class action lawsuits, both of those are focused on misleading statements potentially that were given to investors. DOJ is obviously continuing their investigation on the relationship with Megaspeed. The other big problem here is talent. You got a bunch of employees signing petitions and Travis, no stranger, Travis Kalanick, friend of the pod, No stranger to getting ousted said the employees should do a walkout.

Here's the clip with other bestie Antonio Gracias. A lot of leather jackets on that dais in support of Jensen. The leather jacket protest continues.

Speaker 5 1:02:20

Now, I obviously experienced this. I went through six months of ops. before I went down. I held on as tight as I could, but eventually I just couldn't. But any wisdom I can provide about that experience to Jensen or the team of people around him that I think are ultimately gonna lean in to fight to get him back, because it matters so much,

That's what I'm bringing to the party. People said, hey, is the petition, is that good? I'm like, dude, I sent Jensen the screenshot of the stories when there was a petition for me. I'm like, petition good, walk out better. I didn't get a response.

But I will show up to NVIDIA HQ with a wafer-encrusted megaphone with tons of NVIDIA employees who wanna walk out, tons of CEOs, founders, who believe in what I just said, who are believers and don't want an AI overlord. And let's fight for what's right. And given that, you can't, we don't have control of the outcome. All right, man. But let's fight.

Speaker 1 1:03:29

There it is. The industry lining up behind Jensen. Leather jackets up for Jensen. Jackets for Jensen. Next week, I expect everybody to show up in a leather jacket.

Speaker 3 1:03:39

Your thoughts here, Chamath,

Speaker 1 1:03:40

on the NVIDIA situation. And then we'll go to you, Freeberg.

Speaker 2 1:03:44

I think it's very complicated still to have a definitive opinion beyond the following. He was an exceptional, legendary founder and CEO. He built the most important company in the most important industry in the world. He is

biblically good. He also made a bunch of mistakes. The extent of those are still not known. And the problem is that you can't reinstate somebody like that into a public company with that much valuation that has been destroyed because it just completely throws governance out the window and it puts everybody at risk, everybody, including the company.

So that's why it's not going to happen. And that's why they have to say that. And the unfortunate part is I think Colette is excellent. And she's put in the awkward situation of having to be the message bearer of that. And so then you get the internet trolls that run around and give her a hard time. And it's not her hard time. She's just a messenger.

He is exceptional, that company is exceptional, but they are in a very unique moment where you cannot make any decision. I repeat, you can't make a decision until all of the congressional hearings are done. I mean, I have to stress, these guys have to navigate three different committees on December 1st and 2nd. The Select Committee, the House Intelligence Committee, another committee.

Do you think that that's easy? Does anybody think that what they're going to be spending time with was pillow talk? So everybody needs to just calm down. He's going to be really focused for December the 1st. And hopefully what comes out of that is there is nothing to see here.

But I can guarantee you that if there's one even shred of there is something to see here, it's going to get leaked and there's going to be another wave because the stakes are too high.

right? Because you have an internet mob versus the China hawks versus who knows all of the different players that are at that play here. I don't know. That's why, as I said before, this is so in the too hard bucket. And so the more people blather on about superficial bullshit, the more you actually make it harder for him to come back.

So I would shut the up, and I would let him prepare, and I would hopefully have him nail this and prove categorically that there's nothing to see here, then you can actually start to have a structured conversation. But all these ding-a-ling, bottoms-up protest bull

betrays a fundamental understanding of what is happening, which is congressional closed-door hearings on the record, which could result in some really slippery slope stuff for him, for other people, the company.

And nobody should have an opinion until that's over.

Speaker 1 1:06:34

Okay. Freiburg, what's your opinion? Given Chamath has just admonished everyone for not having one, I'm curious what you're taking and what are your feelings about the situation and the founder being ousted and et cetera?

Speaker 3 1:06:47

Look, what's happened has happened. And I can't go back and change the fact that he resigned. We don't know whether he resigned over concerns about selling chips to China, whether there was espionage, whether it was based on affairs and violations of codes of conduct. We just don't know. The company's not put out a definitive statement. Jensen has not put out any factual statements.

The government has not put out any factual statements or declarations. There has been no

civil or criminal case that's been filed by the government against the company or by any of the government regulators against the company. So we are all just reacting to media that we always say all the time lies to us. So I don't know what to believe. I don't know what's true or what's not true. There have been no official statements from the company from the government, from the regulators, from Jensen, regarding any of the facts of the matter.

Speaker 1 1:07:45

Well, we know there's a report. Well, there are some things we know. There was a report that Rubio rewrote.

We know that there was... Again, Jason, that is a media

Speaker 3 1:07:57

report. What you were referencing is something that some reporter said. I said it's a report. I'm not going to react to media anymore.

Speaker 1 1:08:05

Okay. I don't know

Speaker 3 1:08:08

what's true. All I know is that the actual people, the first parties that matter here, government regulators, government agencies, Jensen and the company, none of them have provided any official data or evidence or proclamations. Everything has come through media. And I don't believe any of it. So I don't know what to

Speaker 2 1:08:25

think. I agree with Freeberg. Everybody, if you want him back, to quote Dave Chappelle, you could just shut the f*** up.

Speaker 1 1:08:33

I will not give my opinion, even though that's your best advice, Jamal. I actually think just looking at the totality of the reports and triangulating on them and knowing what I know about salespeople, this is a case of, and there have been reports of, these servers and cloud providers giving a backdoor into some of this hardware to Chinese companies.

This has always happened where sales of items get flipped and then provided to people. I bet you this is what's going to come out. A bunch of rogue salespeople in a gray area, resellers on resellers selling this, and it will wind up- Maybe you should be

Speaker 2 1:09:15

called as a special witness in December the 1st. Nostradamus. Maybe like what you

Speaker 1 1:09:20

do. But this is a podcast, Chamath.

Speaker 2 1:09:26

What is the role of podcasts in the world? You can look in your dirty paper brown bag of junk and see the future. Awesome. I don't know jack shit. So

Speaker 1 1:09:35

I have chosen to shut the fuck up. That's a great choice. I have chosen to speculate on a podcast, which is my right as an American. If we've learned anything over these years is that the goal of podcasts is to speculate.

Speaker 2 1:09:48

You know what I've realized in the last few weeks? What have you realized? And this is an important thing to realize.

Speaker 1 1:09:52

Here we go.

Speaker 2 1:09:55

I think it's really important. to try to be right. And when you know, you say, and when you don't, you can guess. And when there's so much on every single side, it's just what Friedberg said, where it's so clear that you can't know, it's sometimes just better to just

Speaker 1 1:10:18

Keep your mouth shut. You talked about that two weeks ago with the midterms. When you talked about it on the midterms and you said, hey, listen, I got it all wrong. People were really excited about that money.

Speaker 2 1:10:28

I got it

Speaker 1 1:10:29

wrong. Yeah. I got it totally wrong.

Speaker 2 1:10:31

But this is the thing where I have no opinion because it's like the moment of truth has not come yet. It is a few weeks away. Yeah. And so what everybody else is persecuting is online virtue signaling nonsense. Or speculation. Yeah.

Speaker 1 1:10:46

Yeah.

Speaker 2 1:10:46

And people are speculating. It doesn't have to be virtue signaling. What Freebrook said, it is virtue signaling. What Freebrook said is totally true. Nobody who's in the middle of it has said anything on the record. Nobody.

Nobody. And so what it is, is just a bunch of goofballs on the sidelines with opinions.

Speaker 1 1:11:02

Yes. What you just described is what everybody in the industry is doing. Speculating, yes. Not me? I'm not speculating. I wish him the best.

Speaker 3 1:11:13

I'll tell you what I'm speculating on. I'm speculating on the fact that there's a large-scale, unconscious effort to monopolize artificial intelligence, the greatest technology advancement in human history. And if we don't all fight for the open-source movement and we don't all fight for competition, the last thing any of us want And I think Democrats, Republicans, regardless of your political affiliation or where you sit in the K-shaped economy, no one should want an oligarchy or oligopoly when it comes to AI.

This technology is going to evolve. It is going to move forward. You are not going to stop it. So try and keep it from becoming an oligopoly by allowing the proliferation.

Speaker 2 1:11:54

Here's the numerical receipts. Today, as we speak right now, now it's 1142, okay? The S&P 500 is down 1.39%. The VIX, our vol index, is up 10.83%.

Ant is up from the IPO price 18%. You know what the only other company that's ripping right now is? Palo Alto Networks up 5.86% because they made a huge bet on open source. Freeburg is right. And the market will reward you. And I think what the market is saying is it is philosophically right and it is mathematically right. And I think that that's a really important signal on a day like today.

Speaker 1 1:12:38

Today is a bloodbath out there, folks. Here's your- Oh, go

Speaker 2 1:12:42

ahead, Nostracanus. Look into your paper brown baggage shelf. This is

Speaker 1 1:12:46

more looking at the market heat map, though. This is actually a fact. I can't

Speaker 2 1:12:51

wait to see you, by the way. Why do you think this podcast is

Speaker 1 1:12:54

number one? It's because we speculate. Just because you got burned because you touched the stove, and I told you, that stove's hot, Shamab. Be careful. Be careful. If you get so close to politics, you burnt your hand on the stove. And now all of a sudden you're going to be judicious. The ratings are going to tank. That's

Speaker 2 1:13:10

not what I'm saying. I take speculative bets all the time. What I'm saying is I'm risk off because what I'm telling you right now is the balance of motion in this market is down. It's not up. I'm also smart enough to look at a market and say, what is it rewarding? It's rewarding the creation of one of 10

mega corpse. So we're going to have a mag 10. We know what the mag four or five These guys make it a mag six, okay? So they rewarded that today in a market where vol is up, people are scared, and they're mostly risk off. And they reward what Freeberg said, which is it is very important to now make big bets, use your cashflow, use your stock, get in the game, put on the pads, get on the field, hit somebody.

I'm happy to observe that. I think it's wonderful for Nikesh. It's a brilliant thing that he did. He probably has a really good chance of being a trillion dollar business. and building this thing over the next decade, amazing. I wish him all the best. I am principally risk-off because I think there's a lot yet to come. I'll put it in three buckets.

Economically, there's a lot yet to come. Specifically around AI trade, we don't even know what the first order effects are because we haven't gone through these congressional hearings. Once you get past those hearings, then you're going to figure out what happens when the thread gets pulled out of the bank of Nvidia. We don't know what the implications are for the bank of Nvidia being closed.

And I think the tenor of how closed or open it is will be more obvious after those congressional hearings, not before and not during. And then the third thing is we're in a situation where everything seems to be going down. We're getting cyber hacked every day. Everything is shut down. We're being told to prep for three days. And you don't think the balance of risks are down? Your paper bag tells you it's going to go up.

Speaker 1 1:14:56

Oh, no, it's not a paper bag. I'm looking at the fundamentals of the company. Your

Speaker 2 1:15:00

plastic trash bag tells you that things are going up? No, no, no, no. It's a Louis Vuitton bag. What does Nostra Commas use to look at the future? I'll tell you. I'll tell you. I'll give you the three things.

Speaker 1 1:15:10

Products. Products. management, and markets. That's how I make my bets. Nostradamus

Speaker 3 1:15:16

in his plastic bag. You have

Speaker 1 1:15:18

a dirty brown

Speaker 2 1:15:19

lunch bag.

Speaker 1 1:15:21

Brown bag. No. Trust me. Nostradamus sees the future. And the future is who's shipping great products. You don't see shit. I see it all. You don't see shit. I buy NVIDIA 150 not investment advice. I can't wait to see you in Vegas. I can't wait to see you in Vegas, everybody. Love you, besties. Bye-bye.

Speaker 6 1:15:39

Love you, boys. Bye-bye. to the fans, and they've just gone crazy with it. Love you, Wesley.

We need to get merchies.

Plays from this note through the rest of the episode.

Weekly highlights

One letter a week.

The notes worth hearing, with the minute they were said.