Why Are Stock Buybacks a Warning in an AI Boom?
Chamath Palihapitiya says spending free cash flow on buybacks is a tell that leadership does not know what to buy, what to build, or what to invest in.
Jason Calacanis puts Nvidia's additional buyback authorization at $150 billion last September, before Jensen Huang was ousted, and total buybacks at $235 billion, with the finance chief calling the repurchase a top priority. He also describes years of criticism of Tim Cook for taking about half of Apple's shares off the table with buybacks and dividends. The old pattern, Chamath Palihapitiya says, lifted earnings per share and often delivered about a 5 to 10 percent yearly bid as companies bought part of the float. That game is over when disruption is high. The market then rewards acquisitions that defend the current moat and build new ones. A $4.5 billion acquisition sent the stock up because investors were voting for more deals.
Anthropic Goes Public, Nvidia in Crisis, Markets Tank, Open Source Crackdown? ·
From the transcript
You know what's not going to be valuable? If you take your free cash flow and you spend it on buybacks.
It says a lot about where you don't know where to invest. I mean, that's a good point about NVIDIA. That's exactly
right. That's the tell. When you are like, I'm going to do a buyback, what you're basically saying is, I don't have a clue.
You either don't have the high road and the hootspot to buy something, build something, which would be the other two categories to spend large amounts of money. Big criticism of Apple over the years. Tim Cook's stewardship of that firm was based largely on taking half the shares off the table. Massive buybacks, massive dividends. And if you look at NVIDIA, the CFO, as CFOs are wont to do, brought up.