Why Oppose Labels on Open-source AI Models?
David Friedberg says efforts to curb, restrict, or label open-source AI hand governments a tool for regulated monopolies, and he thinks those efforts limit prosperity and individual liberty.
The origin of the model should not matter, in his view. An open-weight model from a public repository can be run on your own computer, rewritten, and forked. He compares that to Apache servers, Firefox, and Android, which he says is on 70% of phones and kept the internet from being locked down by closed software. He thinks AI is at the same decision. Society can regulate, restrict, or penalize what people do with the output. Labeling the software itself, he says, creates a regulated monopoly for closed products and, if those products line up with government agencies, control over what people and businesses are allowed to do. He does not want that, whatever someone's politics.
Anthropic Goes Public, Nvidia in Crisis, Markets Tank, Open Source Crackdown? ·
From the transcript
Yeah, I think this continues to be the path of tyranny. And any effort to try and curb open source, restrict open source, label open source, and give the government the tools to create effectively regulated monopolies through the anti-open source efforts that are being undertaken, I think is going to both limit human prosperity, limit individual liberty, create an Orwellian state, and I think fundamentally violates freedoms of speech.
And I don't think that the origin of open source software should matter. Some people might disagree. But when you download open weight, open source
model from a repository, which is means a website where these things are stored, and anyone can get a copy of them.