Smash Notes

Back to Big Tech's Ugly Week, Getting Rich At Anthropic, AI Costs Plunge.

Why Are Meta and Amazon Ads Better Placed Than Google?

Ranjan Roy says Meta and Amazon sit in a much better position on advertising because their ads live inside closed products, while Google's open-web model is probably the one most ready for disruption, or disruption is already underway.

Google's ad model depends on websites across the wider web. Sites pay Google to send visitors their way through keywords, and keyword traffic has been the model. Amazon, and Meta through Facebook and Instagram, use closed advertising systems where the ads stay inside each company's own products. Amazon showed how valuable a closed system can be. Meta's ad format is not going anywhere. It will only get more valuable, because people will keep scrolling Instagram and Facebook and seeing ads there.

Open-web advertising is probably the model most ready for disruption, or the disruption is already happening. The closed systems leave Meta and Amazon in a much better position.

Grokipedia·Amazon·Google

Transcript

Big Tech's Ugly Week, Getting Rich At Anthropic, AI Costs Plunge ·

From the transcript

Oh my God, that's terrifying. What's interesting is Google's ad model is dependent on this entire web ecosystem. It's dependent on websites exist, they pay Google to direct traffic to them by keywords, and that's been the model. Amazon and Facebook, or Meta with Facebook and Instagram, have closed ecosystem advertising models. The advertising all lives within...

And honestly, Amazon showed how valuable that can be. Meta, their ads format is not going anywhere. It's only going to get more and more valuable. People are still going to scroll through Instagram and Facebook and see ads within there. So actually... more thinking about it, that open ecosystem of advertising is probably the most ready to be, or is being disrupted already, whereas it puts Meta and Amazon in a much better position.

See in transcript

Big Technology Podcast

More from this episode

  1. What Share of Google Searches End in AI Mode?Ranjan Roy says the share of Google searches that end in AI mode jumped from 2% to 8.9%, and Google does not know how to monetize AI mode yet.
  2. Why Does Meta Lead Ad Revenue by 2028?Alex Kantrowitz reads economist Steve Howe's chart, which puts Meta ahead on ad revenue in 2028 by a good margin after Google led in 2024, because Google has…
  3. Why Does Ranjan Roy Keep an Echo Show in the Kitchen?Ranjan Roy keeps an Echo Show in the kitchen and uses it while cooking. The device is very thirsty.
  4. How Does AI Efficiency Change Data Center Investment?Ranjan Roy says rising compute efficiency fundamentally changes the data center investment story for big technology firms.

People

More answers like this

More with Alex Kantrowitz

Related episodes

Plays from this note through the rest of the episode.

Weekly highlights

One letter a week.

The notes worth hearing, with the minute they were said.