Why Do So Many Neoclouds Fail ClusterMax?
Jordan Nanos says most neoclouds still miss the ClusterMax bar because a seller's market rewards raising money, building data centers, and deploying chips faster than improving the service. Almost two years after the first ClusterMax, and after Semi Analysis coined the term neocloud, many providers have not moved toward what their customers already ask for.
Semi Analysis tracks 323 providers in the Cloud TCO model. Only some are large enough to matter, and fewer pass a recommendation bar that is quite low. The two top failures are security and reliability, and both are dead simple. Companies can still run great businesses without a service customers enjoy and recommend to other people.
Only so many providers can lead, because only so many people truly innovate and everybody else copies them. People who represent buyers find it sad how little progress has shown up since ClusterMax first appeared.
Can AI Keep Growing Exponentially? Let’s Ask SemiAnalysis — With Dylan Patel and Jordan Nanos ·
From the transcript
Look, as people who are trying to represent the interests of buyers, I think it just makes us sad. It's sad to see that like a year and a half almost since the first version of ClusterMax was published, actually approaching two years now.
and since we coined the term neocloud at Semi Analysis, that a lot of people have just not made progress towards the things that we were writing about. And the things we were writing about is just exactly what we talk to the customers of these neoclouds about what they want.
And so I think it's just like the dynamic of it being a seller's market means that the priority for these companies is how can they raise as much money as they can, how can they build data centers as fast as they can, and how can they deploy chips as fast as they can, rather than working on the true quality of the underlying service. And that's a little bit of the dynamic that you see represented there, where people can have these great businesses without actually worrying too much about delivering a great service that their customers really enjoy and recommend to other people.