Smash Notes

Back to 693. What’s Our Job as Humans Anymore?, with Sean Astin & Joel Waldfogel.

What Is the No Fakes Act?

Sean Astin says the No Fakes Act would create, for the first time, an individual intellectual property right in a person's voice and likeness.

He is supporting the bipartisan bill. It would give everyone, not only actors, more control over unauthorized copies of their voices and likenesses, including deepfakes. The effort has been three years in the making, and the coalition now includes YouTube and OpenAI. Those companies want a law that explains what is fair to take down, because a takedown can raise First Amendment problems. Parody, news, and some historical material would stay outside the act. The bill advanced unanimously out of the Senate Judiciary Committee and is waiting for a full Senate vote that has not been scheduled.

Astin says an earlier answer of his was that Congress was not flat-footed, because the issue was hard to understand. A few months ago he thought Congress had enough information and should act quickly. He now says Congress is missing the boat, that people will get hurt if nothing happens fast, and that recovery will be hard.

Transcript

693. What’s Our Job as Humans Anymore? ·

From the transcript

And I personally felt responsible to slow it down. There are two places in particular where Aston is trying to slow down the encroachment of AI. The first is in Hollywood. His union just ratified a four-year deal with the studios, streamers, and production companies that employ performers. The most important thing to the companies was stability.

When they talk about what liabilities they have, they would talk about labor stability as being one of the big dangers that they faced. So they really wanted a longer contract. They wanted a four-year contract when we normally do three. And we're like, well, you know, We see that you want stability. We want stability too. Everybody wants stability, but we're not going to let you use that concept like you guys always do to press down too hard.

See in transcript

Freakonomics Radio

More from this episode

  1. Will James Cameron Replace Actors With AI?Sean Astin says James Cameron will not replace actors with AI, and that Cameron does use AI tools in other parts of filmmaking.
  2. How Many Creative Products Earn Back Their Cost?Joel Waldfogel says maybe 5 or 10 percent of creative products that get substantial investments earn out their advances and make more money than they cost to…
  3. Why Did the Number of E-books on Amazon Triple?Stephen Dubner reports Joel Waldfogel's finding that the number of e-books on Amazon tripled between 2022 and late 2025, and that AI accounts for essentially…
  4. Why Is Kevin Kelly Optimistic About AI?Kevin Kelly is optimistic about AI because he thinks our capacity to solve problems is larger than we think, even though the problems themselves are real.
  5. What Jobs Will Humans Still Do After AI?Kevin Kelly says one of the main jobs left for humans as AI improves is being human.
  6. How Much Time and Carbon Does an AI Feature Film Save?Eline van der Velden says making a film with AI cuts time and cost by about 50 percent, and cuts the carbon footprint by 90 percent, compared with making the…
  7. Who Is Tilly Norwood, the AI Actress?Tilly Norwood is an AI-generated performer created by Eline van der Velden at Particle Six, Stephen Dubner says. Dubner describes a few modes.
  8. Is Tilly Norwood an Actor?Stephen Dubner reads a SAG-AFTRA statement that Tilly Norwood is not an actor.

People

More answers like this

More with Kevin Kelly

Related episodes

Plays from this note through the rest of the episode.

Weekly highlights

One letter a week.

The notes worth hearing, with the minute they were said.