Back to Inside Anthropic’s IPO + How AI agents spy on your messages, with Meredith Whittaker.
Why Does Signal Want an Opt-out From Phone AI?
Meredith Whittaker says Signal blocked screenshots on desktop a little over a year ago, after Microsoft Recall started watching what people did on their computers. Signal is preparing the same kind of block for an AI Siri in iOS 27 and for Gemini on Android. Other phone makers ship their own agents, and an app like Muse can still ask for access from the side.
Signal is asking Microsoft, Apple, and Google for a switch an app developer can use to opt out of AI access to its data. She says the stakes are life or death for investigative reporters, people in Ukraine, and anyone else who uses Signal because no other mass messenger offers the same privacy. Apple leads its AI pitch with privacy and a private cloud, and Signal has had good conversations there. That means verifying the protection, not taking Apple's word for it.
Inside Anthropic’s IPO + How AI agents spy on your messages ·
From the transcript
And, and again, we have to get away from the conversation about these being sort of conscious magical genies and down to the level of the systems architectures that they rely on. And, you know, we are seeing that these, these systems, you know, iOS 27 introducing, you know, Siri AI, Siri AI, if you say, Hey Siri, summarize the screen and signal is open or signals not open, but we'll screenshot that we'll store that screenshot, probably running it through an ocular character recognition system to pull out the text, store that text, we'll likely send it offsite to a remote server for inference and processing.
And then we'll, you know, come back with like your screen says whatever, right? None of those fundamentals are clear to 999% of users who just kind of get an update. And, you know, suddenly Siri behaves a little bit differently. Right. To them, it's just pure convenience, but there's all this stuff going on in the background that may expose them to some risk.