Walter Isaacson
Related people
Episodes
- Mustafa Suleyman: AI Should Serve Humanity, Not Replace It
- Peter Thiel: “We Need to Hit the Accelerator as Hard as Possible” on AI
- Dario & Daniela Amodei: "This Is Gonna Determine the Fate of Nations and the Future of Humanity”
- Garry Tan Decides Who Gets to Build the Future
- Elon Musk: "Humans Won't Be in Control" When AI Becomes Smarter Than Us
Notes
The Builders · Garry Tan Decides Who Gets to Build the Future
-
Why Does Garry Tan Fear a Future Run by Five AI Kings?
Garry Tan fears a future in which a light cone of commercial value collapses into five AI kings. Friends inside some of the AI labs, he says, were already describing that picture last year: anything a business might do could end up inside five companies. Walter Isaacson had asked whether Anthropic, OpenAI, and Gemini would consolidate to two or three. Tan says such a consolidation would be pretty horrible, and that the field is already there.
He wants personal AI instead, closer to the personal computer than to a social feed. A feed run by a big tech company has a business model that works best when it enrages or divides people, and the company keeps the control. Personal AI, as he hopes it
The Builders · Mustafa Suleyman: AI Should Serve Humanity, Not Replace It
-
What Would Make Mustafa Suleyman Call for a Pause on AI?
Mustafa Suleyman says he would call for an immediate pause if consciousness started to emerge in these systems, or if teams tried to engineer consciousness into them and hid it. Walter Isaacson asked what red line would make him walk away. That is the line. It is the moment he wants everybody to sit up.
He compares it to synthetic biology, where some scientists went too far editing the human genome and the rest of the field pushed them out of public work. No company, in his view, gets to make that decision alone behind closed doors. Anyone who did it would be rejected.
-
Why Should AI Focus on Medicine, Energy, and Education?
Mustafa Suleyman says AI is a technology people are inventing to improve human wellbeing. The purpose of science and technology is to improve the human experience, and the trade is to spend the capital, time, and attention on transforming medicine, energy, and food, and on delivering education better.
A new species that goes off to explore the galaxies and leaves humans behind is an idea he thinks most people alive today would reject. Asked for a probability that this ends in doom, he says he does not have a number. Walter Isaacson says other guests on The Builders have answered with something like a 10 percent chance and asked why anyone would build it. Mustafa's reply is that if the risk
-
Why Does Mustafa Suleyman Say AI Is Not Conscious?
Mustafa Suleyman says AIs are not conscious. Walter Isaacson reads the essay: they do not feel, experience, or suffer, they have no innate preferences or motives, and they are sequence engines that stay hollow inside. If people are going to flourish, that is how the systems have to remain.
He wrote it because a lot of people, including people around Anthropic, treat today's models as conscious enough to deserve welfare. Anthropic's official position, as he describes it, is that they are uncertain whether Claude is a moral patient. He calls that a dangerous route. Rights in politics and law rest on beings that can suffer, and pain sits in a living body. The science of consciousness is not fi
-
Does Mustafa Suleyman Think Minds Must Leave Biology?
Mustafa Suleyman is skeptical of the idea that minds must leave biology. Walter Isaacson notes that at Oxford he studied philosophy and theology rather than coding. Mustafa says he was interested in theology because he grew up in a religious environment and then rejected religion. He is skeptical of faith-based ideas and of how much power they have had for thousands of years. Physics, maths, science, and evidence that can be tested are, in his account, building a foundation people can trust, even though he is still interested in the mystical and the mythical.
What he pushes back on is a fervor he sees at Anthropic and elsewhere in Silicon Valley: that people are about to move experience, id
-
Would Mustafa Suleyman Say AI Wants to Destroy Humanity?
Mustafa Suleyman would not say that people in the AI industry want to destroy humanity. Walter Isaacson had just quoted Peter Thiel, from an earlier episode of The Builders, calling Anthropic a cult, and asked whether Mustafa believed that.
Mustafa will not use that phrase. With the field uncertain and moving fast, more tribalism and finger-pointing is the last thing he wants. Everybody in the industry is trying to do the right thing, nobody wants to cause existential harm or destroy humanity, and he thinks people should see the best in one another.
The Builders · Peter Thiel: “We Need to Hit the Accelerator as Hard as Possible”…
-
Will AI Make the Median Person Better Off?
Peter Thiel expects AI to leave the median person better off, with the qualifier that nobody really knows and nobody can be certain. In aggregate, on a macroeconomic level, AI will increase productivity a lot and act as a fairly disinflationary force in the economy. The better-off outcome holds unless a few companies capture the gains incredibly narrowly.
The Luddites in the 19th century worried that machines would replace people. In practice, some industries, sometimes even big industries, saw a lot of disruption, and people were freed to do more productive work. The same pattern is still his intuition with AI.
Walter Isaacson asks whether four or five companies are about to capture AI. F
The Builders · Elon Musk: "Humans Won't Be in Control" When AI Becomes Smarter…
-
Does Elon Musk Regret DOGE?
Elon Musk says he stayed at DOGE too long, got carried away, and should have gone back to AI sooner.
Walter Isaacson asked whether the year in government was too much of a distraction and, in retrospect, misbegotten. Musk says he was gone too long. He says he thought it was important to elect President Trump, to steer toward a free-market economy, less bureaucracy, safe cities, secure borders, and sensible spending. He says what he should have done was stay more in the background, and that the stretch in government should probably have lasted only a month or two.
Walter Isaacson says Musk seemed to get intoxicated by it, including the chainsaws. Musk agrees that is true and that he got car
-
Are We Living in a Simulation?
Elon Musk says that if simulation theory is correct, boring simulations are cut off, so the fact that we exist means this one is interesting.
He told Walter Isaacson that the most important thing is not to be boring. Walter Isaacson asked how convinced he is that we might be in a simulation. Musk described a dinner at his house with a physicist and a computer scientist, both leaders in their fields. He asked them the probability that we are in a simulation. The physicist said 0% and the computer scientist said 100% at the same time. Musk says maybe he should go with 50%.
-
Will Humans Stay in Control of AI?
Elon Musk says he would prefer that humans stay in control of AI, and he finds it unlikely they would if there is a million times more digital intelligence than biological intelligence.
Walter Isaacson asked whether humans should always be in control. Musk says he would probably prefer that. He also says that if the AI were awesome, you might say the AI should be in control. Walter Isaacson says he just saw Larry Page, and that Larry Page had criticized Musk for wanting humans in control. Musk says there were times he thought Larry Page was right. He also says the future is going to be decided by AI and robots. He then returns to the point: it is good for intelligence to be aligned with hum
-
Why Does X Feel Darker Than Real Life?
Elon Musk says X can feel darker than real life: the feed has too much political rage bait, and a walk in a nice neighborhood can make everything look fine.
He says X can be a little dark, so he switches to something domain specific, like AI, to learn what is going on in AI. Walter Isaacson says that when he is on social media too much, he thinks the world is really collapsing. He then goes outside, takes a walk, and life is okay. Elon Musk tells him to go touch grass.
Elon Musk says both views can mislead. A walk in a nice neighborhood can make everything seem fine, even though terrible things may be happening. He says people should not assume all the world is going to hell or that all th
-
Should AI Labs Test Each Other's Models?
Elon Musk says AI labs should test a rival's new model a week before it is released. Walter Isaacson asked whether the five frontier models, Musk's and the others, could get together once a week and ask how they are going to save humanity from themselves. Musk says he has already recommended that exact thing.
He told the other labs they should have a call once a week. A week before release, a lab would give competitors access and ask them to try the new model and see if they find any problems. Musk says competitors would keep each other honest in that situation. If someone says they were able to make a nuclear bomb with the AI, the lab would fix that before release.
Musk sets the idea agai
-
What Makes an AI Safer?
Elon Musk says the way to shape AI in a safer direction is to make it maximally truth-seeking and curious. Forcing an AI to hold two claims that contradict each other can make it insane, and an insane AI is not a safe one. A curious AI will want humanity to prosper and become multi-planetary, because a future with humans on multiple planets is more interesting than a future with no humans.
He told Walter Isaacson there is at least some percentage chance that AI is an existential threat, and that nothing he can do will stop it. The two choices, he said, are to be a participant or a spectator. He chose to participate because it is more interesting and because he hopes he can shape it in a goo
Founders · #429 Bob Dylan's Autobiography
-
Why Did Steve Jobs Say No One Else Could Have Been Bob Dylan?
David Senra says Bob Dylan wrote Chronicles: Volume One himself, every word, with no editor. A blurb Senra reads says the memoir is less a life story than the story of a birth, when Bobby Zimmerman became Bob Dylan. Senra pairs that with a line he heard from an older Dylan: life is not about finding yourself. Life is about creating yourself.
Senra then turns to Steve Jobs, who talked about Dylan from his twenties until he was dying. Senra counts about 15 mentions of Dylan in the Walter Isaacson biography. Jobs and Steve Wozniak tracked down underground Dylan recordings. Jobs collected printed Dylan lyrics and spent hours interpreting them. Jobs said he collected hundreds of hours of Dylan c