Smash Notes

Back to Bill Gates says to prepare for 20 years of ‘tumultuous’ AI disruption, with Bill Gates.

Why Is a Global AI Slowdown So Hard?

Bill Gates says a true AI slowdown is very hard because China would have to agree to go along and compliance would have to be audited, somewhat as with nuclear weapons production. Without an agreement, the path people take is full speed ahead. He wishes there were a clear proposal that would be globally enforceable, and he would be among the people who would say yes. No credible proposal makes a slowdown work, so it is not the center of today's debate.

The debate now is whether government should even pay attention to the dangers. A voluntary offer to call if someone would like is inadequate for what he calls the most dangerous weapon of all time. He does not think it is fair to describe Democrats as simply running against AI. Positions on data-center requirements, privacy, and how children use the systems deserve policy consideration.

Transcript

Bill Gates says to prepare for 20 years of ‘tumultuous’ AI disruption ·

From the transcript

And so we got a good education at the misaligned result of reinforcement learning. One of the arguments to pace the frontier to slow development is to figure out how to build those systems in a more robust, more testable way. Would you support a slowdown if that was the goal? A true slowdown is very hard to induce because there you get people say, OK, will China agree to go along with that? And would you be able to audit compliance with that somewhat like we're able to do with nuclear weapons production? If you don't accept that, then you sort of say, OK, what the heck? Let's go full speed ahead, which I wish there was a clear proposal that would be globally enforceable

to slow down. I would be one of the people who would say, yeah, we should probably do that. But there is no credible proposal that makes that work. And so it's not really the center of today's debate. Today's debate is literally whether the government should even pay attention to the dangers here. You don't even have to show what you're doing and say, oh, voluntary call me if you'd like type thing, which is clearly inadequate to the most dangerous weapon of all time.

See in transcript

Decoder with Nilay Patel

More from this episode

  1. Why Does Bill Gates Fear AI Without Safeguards?Bill Gates says the near-term danger is very high for AI models where all the safeguards can be removed, and quite different from models monitored so cyber…
  2. Why Do People Dismiss AI Risk Warnings?Bill Gates says people dismiss AI risk warnings because past fears about technology, including the job market, never arrived, so the new warnings look like…
  3. What Is Bill Gates's Fix for Unsafe AI?Bill Gates says the only solution is for government to reach out to the industry for expertise and make sure every model maintains safeguards so the model…
  4. Did Bill Gates Fund Gain-of-function Research?No. Bill Gates says nobody has ever accused him or the Gates Foundation of being involved in any gain-of-function research.
  5. What Is Left Unsolved After AI Alignment?Bill Gates says solving AI alignment still leaves the challenges the technology poses to humanity.
  6. Is AI Risk More Imminent Than Climate Change?Yes.
  7. Will AI Data Centers Raise Electric Bills?Bill Gates says AI data centers will find a way to be built somewhere in the United States without raising electric bills, without using too much water, and…
  8. What Happens to White-collar Jobs When AI Is Superhuman?Bill Gates says white-collar skills stop being scarce once AI is superhuman, so work such as telesales, telesupport, and help in an accounting department goes…
  9. Why Does Bill Gates Pick Twenty Years of AI Disruption?Bill Gates picks twenty years as a reasonably safe number for a transition of winners, losers, and a lot of disruption that has to be crossed before a period…
  10. How Will AI Change Gates Foundation Health Work?Bill Gates says AI will accelerate healthcare discovery and delivery across the remaining 19 years of the Gates Foundation.
  11. Why Will Lawsuits Fail to Keep AI Safe?Bill Gates says lawsuits will fail to keep AI safe because the danger comes from people who take models without safeguards, not from the AI companies a court…
  12. Will AI Solve Food Shortages and Disease?Bill Gates says AI will solve food shortages and disease, including food shortages that are still real in Africa and not in the United States, and diseases…

People

More answers like this

More with Bill Gates

More with Nilay Patel

Related episodes

Plays from this note through the rest of the episode.

Weekly highlights

One letter a week.

The notes worth hearing, with the minute they were said.