Back to Peter Thiel: “We Need to Hit the Accelerator as Hard as Possible” on AI, with Peter Thiel.
Is Evil Better Than Incompetence?
Peter Thiel ranks good above evil, and evil above incompetence. Bad, in this ranking, means incompetent, and it does matter that the people building these companies avoid being evil.
Appearing not to be evil can be a fake PR stunt. Bill Gates is into virtue signaling and Elon Musk is into vice signaling, and vice signaling may be more honest, even the mark of a better person. A Ferrari is an evil car in the example because it does not get many miles to the gallon. A Trabi that does not work is worse than a golf cart because it breaks down all the time, which makes it a bad car. Better to be good than evil. When a bland bureaucrat stands for bad, the bureaucrat is incompetent, while the person called evil gets something done. Elon Musk gets described as evil and also as irrelevant, yet to the extent he is described as evil he is at least not described as bad.
The same split is the difference between Marlowe's Faust and Goethe's Faust. Marlowe's Faust is a fake scientist, a fraud, a magician and trickster, a fake alchemist who rips people off and goes straight to hell. Goethe's Faust works with the devil, does more good than evil, and gets saved. He prefers Goethe to Marlowe. He does not think of himself as the devil in that story, or as Faust.
Peter Thiel: “We Need to Hit the Accelerator as Hard as Possible” on AI ·
From the transcript
They're still more good than bad. And the alternate view to it is not that these people are more evil than good. The alternate view is they don't matter at all. And that, you know, there are no great men. There are no charismatic leaders. It doesn't matter who they are at all. And these people do matter. These builders. Does it matter that they avoid being evil?
Peter Robinson Yes. I think yes on all these versions of that. Peter Robinson But of course, there's always a lot of complexity to that too, where maybe appearing not to be evil is just a fake PR stunt at this point. Peter Robinson And so maybe Bill Gates is into virtue signaling, Elon Musk is into vice signaling, and in our world, maybe you're more honest if you vice signal than if you virtue signal.