Back to Julie Zhuo: The Miseducation, with Julie Zhuo.
How Do People Learn Product Development Best?
Julie Zhuo believes people learn product development far more when they create the process themselves and then reflect on whether they believe it is the best idea. Naming the success outcome and asking a group to figure out the right way to build the product teaches more than handing them a method and telling them to implement it.
When a team lands on an approach she has tried before and thinks will probably fail, saying so outright teaches less than letting them try it, see why it fails, and run a retrospective together. She used to shut the idea down and tell people not to build it that way. A story from one context rarely convinces anyone, because people ask how she knows the same failure will show up in a new context, and one story cannot carry the nuance. A stronger move, at least sometimes, is to stop and pose a hypothetical: if they start on the path, it fails, and two weeks are gone, what then? Usually someone suggests trying the risky idea earlier so the group will know in a day or two. She can add that, in her experience, the failure comes up a lot, and share what people do then. The team is still designing the entire way. Prescribing a ready-made solution skips the creation and the reflection.
Julie Zhuo: The Miseducation ·
From the transcript
We're going to do this. We're going to have a group. We're going to do a brainstorm. We're going to take the best vote on the idea. Then we're going to implement it. That's not really teaching people, like, what is the art of how you think about getting to product development. It's almost better to... sit a group of people down and say, Hey, we're, you guys are going to design a way of building this product.
Okay. And here's what the success outcome would look like. Why don't you guys figure out what is the right process? And they'll come up with something and let's say like they come up with something and in my head I'm like, Oh, like I've tried that before. It's probably not going to work. i could say that but i don't know that that actually teaches them as much it's almost like if they go through it and they try it and then they realize it doesn't work for these lessons for these reasons and then they retrospect on it that is what is going to get them to really learn why that particular methodology isn't going to work.