Back to Jason Yuan: For the Plot, with Jason Yuan.
Why Is Every Relationship a Story?
Jason Yuan says every relationship is a story with shared authorship between two people. The self in isolation does not exist, even though internal identity does. Calling yourself a good friend only works if a bad friend can exist. As the only person on earth, there is nothing left to identify against. Dot can know a life because it was told about it, and that private record still cannot show that the toxic, emotionally unavailable man is you. Other people have to co-author the story. The world is a collection of stories people write together.
The detail that matters is narrative ambiguity. One account can call Soleio an amazing best friend while Soleio says Jason is okay and that he sees him once a year. The aim is coherence where the two accounts do not match, rather than one agreed label. Soleio adds that Facebook treated friendship as a mutually agreed, symmetric bond, while real relationships carry asymmetries that are more common in nature. Hivemind, as a theory, is a way to show what a social product should actually represent.
From the transcript
And so how did the experience of that then sort of start to tee up and act as the soil from which Highline grew? What happened there? I realized that the self in isolation doesn't exist. This is not to say we don't have internal identity. It's that like, how do I say if I'm a good friend? There needs to be such a thing as a bad friend, right? If I'm like the only person on earth, I have no identity because there's nothing to identify.
And then I'm like, oh my God, like Dot can know all this stuff about me and my life because I told her these things. But what if I'm having delusional psychosis? What if like the toxic, emotionally unavailable man is me? I want to know if I'm the problem. But the only way I can know that is if other people have a chance to co-author the story, right? And that's what the world is.