Smash Notes

Back to The Professor Bringing Sanity Back To Elite Campuses | KMP Ep.55, with Gad Saad.

How Do Civilizations Die?

Gad Saad says civilizations do not die by murder. They die by suicide. The form of suicide the West has chosen is pathological empathy.

Katie Miller asked about the decay of civilization and whether Rome fits. Gad Saad said Rome certainly does, then widened the claim. In the first chapter of Suicidal Empathy, he cites Arnold Toynbee, an eminent British historian who had done a 12-volume study of why civilizations eventually perish. Toynbee came up with a maxim. Gad Saad says the maxim is very relevant to the topic of the book. The maxim is that civilizations do not die by murder. They die by suicide.

Gad Saad argues that the suicidal manifestation the West has chosen runs through pathological empathy. The West, on his account, is not being murdered from outside. It is destroying itself.

Grokipedia·Gad Saad·Katie Miller

Transcript

The Professor Bringing Sanity Back To Elite Campuses | KMP Ep.55 ·

The Katie Miller Podcast

More from this episode

  1. What Languages Do Gad Saad's Children Speak?Gad Saad's children speak only two languages, French and English. His wife speaks neither Arabic nor Hebrew, and he does not speak Armenian.
  2. What Is Suicidal Empathy?Suicidal empathy is compassion that fires too hard at the wrong target.
  3. Why Did Gad Saad Leave Montreal?Gad Saad left Canada for the United States because it became untenable to remain in Montreal, which he calls a hotbed of Islamic takeover.
  4. What Is the Crisis Among Young Men?Katie Miller describes a crisis among young men. Fewer are going to college, many are not dating or marrying, and some are withdrawing from the workforce.
  5. What Does Gad Saad Call Siding With Lindsay Clancy?Gad Saad says siding with Lindsay Clancy is suicidal empathy. He defines it as empathy hyperactivated in the wrong situations and aimed at the wrong targets.
  6. How Lopsided Are Democrats and Republicans Among Professors?Gad Saad says the lopsidedness of Democrats versus Republicans among professors is 1 to 130.
  7. How Does Gad Saad Use Grok?Gad Saad only uses AI to ask very detailed questions.

People

More answers like this

More with Katie Miller

Related episodes

Plays from this note through the rest of the episode.

Weekly highlights

One letter a week.

The notes worth hearing, with the minute they were said.