Smash Notes

Back to The Professor Bringing Sanity Back To Elite Campuses | KMP Ep.55, with Gad Saad.

What Is Suicidal Empathy?

Suicidal empathy is compassion that fires too hard at the wrong target. Gad Saad says empathy is a wonderful virtue for a social species, and a real conversation needs cognitive empathy, or theory of mind. Aristotle taught several thousand years ago that too little of something is bad and too much is bad, so people have to find the middle. No empathy makes a person a psychopath. Empathy that hyperfires in the wrong situations toward the wrong target becomes suicidal empathy.

Society has moved away from logical questions such as whether an idea is right or wrong and whether two plus two equals four. Gad Saad says the demand now is empathy for a lived experience even to the detriment of others. In 2020 he wrote The Parasitic Mind about thought processes that get hijacked. Suicidal empathy is the same parasitism of the emotional system. Hijack both thinking and feeling, and you own the person. Cultural relativism, a parasitic idea, says nobody may judge another culture, even when it cuts off the clitorises of five-year-old girls or practices honor killings. Accept the idea and you cannot decide who should enter the country. Everybody is welcome, which makes open border policies a form of suicidal empathy. He sees the same pattern in transgenderism in sports: biological women lose a place on the podium while the transgender person is treated as holier and more worthy of empathy.

Grokipedia·Gad Saad

Transcript

The Professor Bringing Sanity Back To Elite Campuses | KMP Ep.55 ·

From the transcript

Makes sense. Your new book, Societal Empathy, talks about how ordinary human compassion has crossed the line into something destructive. How did we get to this place in society now where empathy can sometimes matter more than whether an idea of true policy works? So let me first explain what the book is not. It's not an attack on empathy.

Empathy is a wonderful virtue to possess. We are a social species. For you and I, Katie, to have a meaningful conversation, I need to put myself in your mind and vice versa, that's called cognitive empathy or theory of mind. But like Aristotle explained to us several thousand years ago, too little of something is not good. Too much of something is not good.

And you have to find that middle sweet spot. So if I have no empathy, I'm a psychopath. If I have too much empathy, if it hyperfires in the wrong situations towards the wrong target, you end up with suicidal empathy. But so much of society has moved from answering questions on this purely logical basis, right? Is this right? Is this wrong? Does two plus two equal four? Right.

See in transcript

The Katie Miller Podcast

More from this episode

  1. What Languages Do Gad Saad's Children Speak?Gad Saad's children speak only two languages, French and English. His wife speaks neither Arabic nor Hebrew, and he does not speak Armenian.
  2. Why Did Gad Saad Leave Montreal?Gad Saad left Canada for the United States because it became untenable to remain in Montreal, which he calls a hotbed of Islamic takeover.
  3. How Do Civilizations Die?Gad Saad says civilizations do not die by murder. They die by suicide. The form of suicide the West has chosen is pathological empathy.
  4. What Is the Crisis Among Young Men?Katie Miller describes a crisis among young men. Fewer are going to college, many are not dating or marrying, and some are withdrawing from the workforce.
  5. What Does Gad Saad Call Siding With Lindsay Clancy?Gad Saad says siding with Lindsay Clancy is suicidal empathy. He defines it as empathy hyperactivated in the wrong situations and aimed at the wrong targets.
  6. How Lopsided Are Democrats and Republicans Among Professors?Gad Saad says the lopsidedness of Democrats versus Republicans among professors is 1 to 130.
  7. How Does Gad Saad Use Grok?Gad Saad only uses AI to ask very detailed questions.

People

More answers like this

The other side

More with Katie Miller

Related episodes

Plays from this note through the rest of the episode.

Weekly highlights

One letter a week.

The notes worth hearing, with the minute they were said.