Back to The Bumpy Road To AGI — With Kevin Roose, with Kevin Roose.
What Is the Red Queen Race in AI?
Kevin Roose calls the AI race a Red Queen race, a term from evolutionary biology for a survival-of-the-fittest contest among rivals. No matter how fast a lab goes, someone else is always going faster, so the labs race just to stay in the same place. He left less reassured than at his starting point that the technology can be developed safely.
He went in thinking there were grownups in the room and they seemed trustworthy. He liked that AI leaders seemed to take safety and the harms of their products very seriously, at least next to social media, which he grew up covering. Mark Zuckerberg was not going around during the early days of Facebook saying the product could kill millions of people. Facebook was just promoting the benefits. AI leaders said from the get-go that they were fearful of the technology and thought it could have enormous harms. Part of him trusted that instinct, or at least he was glad they were thinking about the downsides so early. Then the pattern locked in: OpenAI releases a better model, so Anthropic has to release a better model, so Google has to release a better model. The labs never quite get where they are going.
The early talk of harm did not slow the contest. Fear of the technology and a race to hold position now sit side by side, and the second one is what left him less reassured.
The Bumpy Road To AGI — With Kevin Roose ·
From the transcript
from your starting point? Less reassured. I went in thinking, okay, there are some grownups in the room and they seem like they're trustworthy. I liked, for example, that the AI leaders seem to take safety and the harms of their products very seriously, at least compared, like you and I both grew up covering social media. That's right. And Mark Zuckerberg was not going around during the early days of Facebook saying like, this product could kill millions of people.
they were just promoting the benefits. What stuck out to me about the AI leaders is from the get-go, they were saying, we are fearful of this technology, we think it could have enormous harms. So part of me trusted that instinct or at least was glad that they were thinking about the downsides of the technology so early. But then you just realize there is this race.