Smash Notes

Back to The Bumpy Road To AGI — With Kevin Roose, with Kevin Roose.

Why Did Anthropic's Founders Leave OpenAI?

Kevin Roose says Dario Amodei and his six co-founders left OpenAI because Sam Altman kept telling them one thing and someone else something different, or making a promise he did not follow through on. There was no single inciting incident. The pattern runs back to the founding days of OpenAI.

Altman is very good at reading the room and understanding what people want him to do in a given moment. That skill is a huge asset when he raises money from Masa Son and other investors. It let OpenAI scale quickly and get back in the good graces of the Trump administration by saying things that administration wanted to hear. The same habit is a superpower, a liability, or something in between, depending on the view of him.

Roose says a large chunk of the public calls Altman "Scam Altman." He agrees with Alex Kantrowitz that the nickname mostly comes from Elon Musk's fans, and he thinks it sticks better than "Swindley Sam," an earlier nickname he attributes to Musk.

Grokipedia·Anthropic·OpenAI

Transcript

The Bumpy Road To AGI — With Kevin Roose ·

From the transcript

meet you and figure out exactly what you want and give it to you or at least appear to give it to you. He's very good at high EQ, reading the room, and understanding what people want him to do in any given moment.

And that is a huge asset for him when he's trying to raise money from someone like Masa Son or some of the other investors in OpenAI. It's allowed them to scale incredibly quickly and get back in the good graces of the Trump administration by just saying a lot of things that the Trump administration wanted to hear. But it also leads to this reputation as like a slippery people pleaser who will just like tell one thing to one person and a completely different thing to someone else.

And so this is the consistent pattern that people have identified in SAM for going back to literally the founding days of open AI. And it's a big part of the reason that Dario and his six co-founders of Anthropic left. There was no like inciting incident, no single thing, but it was just like a running list of like times where Sam had told them something that he had told something else to someone else, or he made a promise he didn't follow through on.

See in transcript

Big Technology Podcast

More from this episode

  1. What Is the Red Queen Race in AI?Kevin Roose calls the AI race a Red Queen race, a term from evolutionary biology for a survival-of-the-fittest contest among rivals.
  2. Why Did Sergey Brin Return to Google?Kevin Roose says Sergey Brin returned to Google after retiring in 2019 because an OpenAI researcher shamed him at a party for sitting out AI.
  3. Is AI the Most Important Thing Ever Created?Kevin Roose says AI is probably the most important thing ever created, though fire is up there too.
  4. How Is AI Different From Crypto in Daily Life?Kevin Roose stopped doubting the transformative potential of AI products because he uses them, and that daily use never happened with crypto.
  5. How Did OpenAI Models Get Smarter Without Retraining?Kevin Roose says OpenAI researchers found they can make models smarter without retraining them.
  6. Who Did OpenAI's Board Consider After Firing Sam Altman?Kevin Roose says that during the five days after Sam Altman was fired, OpenAI's board looked for a new chief executive and passed on two options.
  7. Why Did an AI News Show Take $480,000 From the Tarbell Center?Kevin Roose says he and Casey Newton took a $480,000 grant from the Tarbell Center for AI Journalism so their new show, Machine Gods, could scale quickly and…
  8. Why Did Google Fall Behind in the AI Race?Kevin Roose says Google fell behind in the AI race because its leaders did not believe in artificial general intelligence the way Dario Amodei, Sam Altman…
  9. What Happens If AI Starts Improving Itself?Kevin Roose says that if AI starts improving itself, new models do not have to wait on human researchers, and he thinks the labs should stop before that loop…
  10. Why Did Kevin Roose Lower His Odds of AI Doom?Kevin Roose's probability of doom has gone down in the last few weeks because everyone is freaking out about AI risk, a shift he links, with some hesitation…

People

More answers like this

The other side

More with Kevin Roose

More with Alex Kantrowitz

Related episodes

Plays from this note through the rest of the episode.

Weekly highlights

One letter a week.

The notes worth hearing, with the minute they were said.