Smash Notes

Back to A Better Way to Think About Tech.

What Is Technoselectionism?

Cal Newport defines technoselectionism as a different route between two bad maps of progress. A pessimist path circles the current moment to avoid danger. An optimist path runs straight at a better future and crosses the pain on the way. In a New Yorker article, he calls technoselectionism a perspective that accepts innovations can significantly improve our lives, and that also holds we can build new things without treating every popular invention as inevitable. People who experiment with what comes next should still be encouraged and rewarded. Some experiments cause more bad than good.

The same stance can be enthusiastic about artificial intelligence and still block it in some settings, or marvel at the social internet without surrendering kids' mental lives to TikTok. Newport's rule is to repudiate technologies that are clearly causing net harm, keep embracing ones that seem more beneficial, and aim that techno-social evolution more intentionally. Put plainly, technology should advance, but not without curation, change, analysis, and intention.

On the map, a technoselectionist still tries to reach the better future and tries to steer around the obstacles, knowing a careful line may still clip one. The role is active: shape how technology is adopted and developed so the good is maximized and as many harms as possible are avoided.

Transcript

A Better Way to Think About Tech ·

From the transcript

Technoselectionism is going to offer us a different route. Now, before I show it to you on this visual metaphor, let's take this down for a second, Jesse, because I'm going to load up that New Yorker article we talked about. And I want to read to you how I define technoselectionism, and then we'll go back and we'll add it to our visual metaphor of a map.

All right, so I bring up on the screen here a key quote from that New Yorker article. I'm going to read this here from the article. Technoselectionism is a perspective... that accepts the idea that innovations can significantly improve our lives, but also holds that we can build new things without having to accept every popular invention is inevitable.

See in transcript

Deep Questions with Cal Newport

More from this episode

  1. Why Are Tech Debates Stuck Between Optimists and Pessimists?Cal Newport says technology talk gets stuck because commentators split into two extreme camps.
  2. What Is the First Step to Being a Techno-selectionist?Cal Newport says the first action in a techno-selectionist mindset is choosing which technology you use and which you do not.
  3. What Are Fences in Digital Minimalism?Cal Newport calls fences the rules you set when you still use a technology but refuse the default way of using it.
  4. Why Did Social Networks Copy TikTok?Cal Newport says Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter copied TikTok after the app started taking their users. TikTok ignores friends, follows, and the social graph.
  5. Why Did 2025 Bring All-day School Phone Bans?Cal Newport says the 2025 bell-to-bell smartphone bans in schools across the country came from parents, not from schools getting new data or having a change…
  6. How Should Students Use AI Chatbots to Study?Cal Newport calls a careful chatbot habit techno-selectionism applied to large language model chatbots: choose uses that promote what you value and avoid…
  7. Why Can Offloading Hard Work to AI Hurt Mental Health?Cal Newport says an overlooked cost of using too much AI is the loss of hard work that supports mental health, not only thinking skill.
  8. How Can Newspapers Replace Social Media?Cal Newport says newspapers can replace a social media habit and still leave a person current on the world.
  9. Why Did Lawrence Wright Keep Research in a Filing Cabinet?Cal Newport points to Lawrence Wright's filing cabinet to show why slow research can beat an AI agent.

People

More answers like this

The other side

More with Cal Newport

Related episodes

Plays from this note through the rest of the episode.

Weekly highlights

One letter a week.

The notes worth hearing, with the minute they were said.