Back to Mercurial Artifacts with Nicholas Jitkoff, with Nicholas Jitkoff.
Why Can the Arc Browser Try a Different Design?
Nicholas Jitkoff says the Arc browser can try a different design because it starts with a smaller user base and already has the learnings of earlier browsers built in.
A lot of the work becomes refinement once people expect the product to be a certain thing. A designer can argue that the job is to tear down the walls and make the hard choices of refactoring the experience. Hundreds of millions of people use the product every day, and they are not delighted when a gaping hole appears where they expected a key bit of functionality. They bump into muscle memory that had become invisible from using a browser day in and day out. The fight is almost like fighting the design of a car.
A smaller user base is what lets Arc try a different approach to a similar problem, with the learnings of the browsers that came before already built in.
Mercurial Artifacts with Nicholas Jitkoff ·
From the transcript
there was a single search box rather than two. A lot of it becomes more refinement. Right. Because there's expectations from people around what the product is at a certain point. Right. And there's also the tension around like, well, you can argue on the one hand, it's a designer's mandate to go and tear down the walls and make the hard choices of refactoring the experience.
But on the other hand, if you have hundreds of millions of people that use the product every day, they're not going to be delighted with the fact that there's now a gaping hole where they were expecting a key bit of functionality to be. And they're bumping up against all their muscle memory that had become invisible by virtue of using a browser day in and day out.