Back to Luca Ferrari - Building Bending Spoons, with Luca Ferrari.
Why Has Bending Spoons Never Lost an Acquisition Bid?
Luca Ferrari says Bending Spoons has never lost a bid. No company they offered on went to someone else. When they did not buy, the seller chose not to sell to anyone. That means the offers are usually very competitive, and also that they are probably weak negotiators. A few lost bids would be a sharper strategy, because a miss is how you learn.
They look at thousands of businesses a year and do not offer on thousands. He would say they probably offer on about twice as many as they buy. They open near a fair price and barely haggle. Naming the maximum immediately is fast and stupid, and so is a ridiculously low price. They sit much closer to the high end, in what he calls the Warren Buffett pattern: a very good offer, a no is acceptable, and another 25 percent is not there just for asking. If the seller wants more than they will pay, they walk on rather than fall in love with that one business.
The price comes from assumptions, not from a gift for prediction. They can pay well because they can run the company better, after twelve years in the details. Each assumption has a probability distribution. The team debates the inputs and must not see the model output, because a weak-looking plan tempts people to relax a conservative guess. A Monte Carlo then produces a distribution of IRR, and that output stands. Nobody gets to reopen the assumptions afterward.
Luca Ferrari - Building Bending Spoons ·
From the transcript
One is how do you determine your returns as a function of price? The second one is how do we stay disciplined so we will really not pay more than we believe is right based on our expected returns, opportunity cost, what else we could be doing with that capital and what returns. So the first one is a matter of sophistication. And the second one is a matter of psychology, really, I think, discipline, patience.
And the third one is, how well do we negotiate? How efficient are we at positioning the ultimate price on that curve? The fastest but stupidest approach would be to immediately offer the very most you can pay. The opposite of offering a ridiculously low price is probably equally stupid. So you want to find the right balance. Interestingly, actually, are much closer to the former.