Patrick O'Shaughnessy
Related people
- Andrew Huberman
- Christina Cacioppo
- Cliff Sosin
- David Vélez
- Gabe Stengel
- Luca Ferrari
- Martin Casado
- Michael Moritz
Podcasts
Episodes
- Michael Moritz - Lessons From 40 Years of Investing and Writing
- Luca Ferrari - Building Bending Spoons
- Noah Shinn - Building Instinct: The Personal Agent
- Andrew Huberman - The Frontier of Neurotechnology
- Cliff Sosin - Owning the Complements to Intelligence
- Gabe Stengel - Building Investing Superintelligence
- Martin Casado on Frontier Model Economics, AI's Slowdown, and the Cursor Deal
- David Vélez - Building Nubank and the Future of Global Banking
- Christina Cacioppo - Building an Enduring Software Company in the Age of AI
- Ramtin Naimi on the State of Venture Investing
Notes
Invest Like the Best with Patrick O'Shaughnessy · Ramtin Naimi on the State of Venture Investing
-
What Is the Biggest Mistake Ramtin Naimi Made Building Abstract?
Ramtin Naimi says the biggest mistake he has made building Abstract is raising every fund too small. On every fund, he could have kept an identical return profile with about twice the capital. Limited partners would have received the same quality of return. Founders would have received more capital. Abstract would have led rounds more often, instead of coming in as a co-investor, and the firm would also be known for leading later-stage financings.
Limited-partner comments on size flipped with the market. The first fund was $100 million in 2018, and limited partners told him a first-time fund of that size was too big and that he should raise less. The latest fund is $800 million, and limited
-
Is the Current Venture Cycle More Like 2019 or 2021?
Ramtin Naimi says the current venture cycle could still be 2019 rather than 2021, even where the behavior rhymes with the last boom. In 2021 the companies were not that interesting. SaaS businesses growing 5x, then 3x, 3x, and 2x were called best in class. A company with $8 million of SaaS revenue and a very constrained TAM could raise at a billion-dollar valuation, and a seven-year path to $100 million of annual recurring revenue was the exciting case. Round structure, deal volume, and the pressure to keep up with the market all look similar. There was a six-month window in 2021 when firms were ripping checks, and a lot of the investors from that window look back and wonder what they were t
-
Why Are Hot Venture Rounds Getting a Second, Pricier Tranche?
Ramtin Naimi says the hottest companies now sell a second, much more expensive slice of the same round to the firms that lost the first one. A handful of firms get preferential pricing, which he calls tranche number one. Firms that lose the deal used to keep a relationship with a small check and wait for the next round. In 2021 a fast follow a couple of weeks later came in at about 2x the valuation. In the current market the losing firms do not want to wait for the next round. They ask what they have to pay to get into the financing the same day, and the price is usually not 2x. It is usually three, four, or five times the primary price, raised in tandem with the primary. He calls that slice
-
Why Is Silicon Valley the Best Place to Start a Company?
Ramtin Naimi says Silicon Valley stays the best place in the world to start a company because of how many people there write personal checks before any institution shows up.
No other startup region has ever taken off the same way. Silicon Valley has the largest density of individual check-writers by an order of magnitude, probably 100x or greater. People there run around writing 100k to $1 million personal checks off their own balance sheets to put companies in business before they are institutional. Some employee balance sheets are already the size of a huge angel fund or a huge seed fund. A person will write a million dollar check and, if the money is lost, will not care. The mentality be
-
Why Do Seed Deals Assume a Trillion Dollar Outcome?
Ramtin Naimi says seed prices follow a moving goalpost for how big a startup might become, and the current goalpost is a trillion-dollar outcome. In 2016, when he started early-stage investing, people priced every company as if the best case were a $10 billion outcome. Toward 2021, Stripe, Databricks, Airbnb, and DoorDash approached $100 billion valuations, and investors priced other companies as if a $100 billion best case applied to them. Only the companies already on track to be worth $100 billion in 2021, give or take two or three more, actually got there.
SpaceX, Anthropic, and OpenAI are three trillion-dollar companies. He bets there might be two to three more, not 40, yet people now
-
Why Is One Neolab Spending a Billion Dollars on a Single Training Run?
Ramtin Naimi says a neo lab he met a couple of weeks ago was raising $1 billion in a financing he thinks was its second round, and planned to spend the entire billion next year on compute for one training run. The company said it would probably need to raise another $5 billion throughout next year.
People once expected two or three great neo labs. The count is now probably 80 or 90 neo labs that have raised somewhere between $1 billion and $5 billion. The segment is still small beside the hyperscalers, and the combined scale is not small. All of them need to raise tons of cash, and underwriting how well they are doing is very hard. The practical read often tracks how well they are doing and
-
What Is the Customer Value Fund?
Ramtin Naimi says GC's customer value fund finances growth when a company can prove that every $10 million unlocks $30 million of revenue. Patrick O'Shaughnessy calls the fund enormously successful as a product, and it has raised tons of money.
Some venture firms now finance companies with compute as opposed to cash. For a lot of the founders, bringing compute instead of cash is more attractive, because the company will spend the round on compute and the compute can lock in the allocation. The firm still has to secure the compute and get good pricing, then decide whether the compute lasts in perpetuity or covers one training run, and whether the same amount can be recycled three times, two
-
Why Are Mega Venture Funds Raising Two or Three Times in One Cycle?
Ramtin Naimi says mega platform funds have probably raised two to three times inside a single 18 to 24 month window, so deployment is about 3x faster than the firms expected.
A venture fund normally raises for an 18 to 24 month initial deployment period, the cash it wants to put into first checks, and then reserves follow-on money to keep financing companies and maintain ownership. Firms raise an amount that fits a portfolio model: a set number of bets and a set ownership level over an 18 to 24 month period. Every mega firm dramatically underestimated how much capital it takes to get that ownership. A larger number of companies looked worth backing, prices were higher, and the checks requir
Invest Like the Best with Patrick O'Shaughnessy · Martin Casado on Frontier Model Economics, AI's Slowdown, and the…
-
How Did the Cursor Deal Come Together?
Martin Casado says the Cursor deal came together off a raise that was already closing, once building models required compute few people have. Cursor was about to finish raising a few billion dollars when Mythos came out. Working backward, Mythos probably cost about $3 billion to make. Building models meant Cursor needed more money and access to that compute, which opened the strategic conversations.
Interest followed because Cursor had by far the most users and by far the most data. SpaceX had the compute. Cursor had the data and a team that had already built models, and code mattered. The raise helped set the price. The deal was fairly straightforward.
-
How Do Frontier AI Models Keep Pricing Power?
Martin Casado says frontier AI models keep pricing power because the market is still large and growing, and buyers want the smartest model. Three years of data show that being even slightly better than the next model brings tremendous pricing power. The best frontier models take 80% or more of the market, dollar weighted, and demand looks basically unlimited.
Penetration is still tiny: about 0.1%, or something close to it. Enterprises are said to be about 3% penetrated, and the budget share is about 1% or less. Nothing structural changes who gets paid as long as the market keeps growing and does not saturate. If pockets of the market saturate, or growth slows for another reason, the outcome
-
Why Do Traditional Investors Miss Disruptive Technology?
Martin Casado says traditional investors miss disruptive technology because they judge revenue quality before anyone knows the pricing model. Business models always lag disruptive technologies. Nobody knew how to monetize the internet at the start, and the shift from perpetual to recurring took years of argument.
A traditional finance mindset, applied too early, is not evaluating the technology or its disruptive power. It looks at the quality of revenue, which pulls the investor toward technology that is not disruptive, because a disruptive product often has no known business model and no known market size. If the belief is that technology creates the market, market size is the wrong worry.
-
Has Software Become a Capital Problem?
Martin Casado believes software has become a capital problem, and he treats the shift as industrial-revolution scale.
The industrial revolution moved the world from a zero-sum contest to a non-zero-sum one, where net new value is created. He sees the same kind of shift now. Solving problems used to mean very complex engineering that did not scale, was very tough, and then had to be maintained, which is why all software has always sucked. He does not know about the real world yet and thinks it will get there, but the work has turned into a capital resourcing problem. Capital allocators are in a strategic position to drive the future more directly than before, because a scale-up capital game
-
What Does Martin Casado Believe About Private Market Money?
Martin Casado believes money put into private markets grows private markets. Capital creates opportunities, markets, and value, so extra funding does not mean private markets are overfunded.
A common view holds that venture capital is not an asset class, that only 20 startups matter, and that too much money going in overfunds private markets. Over the last 20 years far more money has entered private markets, and the value has kept pace through massive private companies, many opportunities, and very large exits. Venture investors create value because technology creates value, and putting more money in makes private markets grow. The opposite mindset is surprisingly common. A senior GP who ha
-
What Was Larry Page Asked About Orbital Compute?
Martin Casado heard that someone asked Larry Page how much compute will be orbital. Page said five nines, because it is just physics and eventually all of it will be in space. Putting computing in space also pencils out, and regulation is the reason the move makes the most sense.
Power, chips, and materials are the real constraint. With that limit, 80% goes to the scale providers and 20% goes to hard-to-reach, niche places, including his relationship with a government that has the power. A GPU marketplace he met was running many of its GPUs in converted chicken sheds and chicken coops on farms. The market is so large that a significant portion never makes sense for operators like SpaceX, an
-
What Is the Mythical Man Month?
Martin Casado says the mythical man month means you cannot increase the speed of engineering by adding people. The effect is very sublinear, like a natural law, because extra people add organizational communication. One author laid it out in the 70s. Software projects that were meant to ship faster went slower once more people were thrown at them. Engineering has always been the bottleneck.
Ten years ago, five founders who asked for a billion dollars and got it would have left the money sitting there or hired a bunch of engineers and detonated the company. He spent 10 years on a startup that became a very large business, and the limit held: engineering does not scale, so capital could not b
-
Was Early Internet Security Worse Than Now?
Martin Casado lived through the early internet on the ground, with formal studies in security, and the era was way worse than the breaches happening now. Worms had already cost billions of dollars in economic damage and had taken out critical infrastructure.
A Windows 95 machine connected to the internet during installation was infected before the installer finished, with no time to patch it. A new technology that changes how computers run always changes the security posture, and the industry is in another moment of the same kind. A few years of mayhem come first, breaches cause real issues, and then the industry evolves. The usual test is whether the good guys can spend more money than the
-
Why Do Startups Always Buy the Smartest AI Model?
Martin Casado says two competing startups never pick a dumber model to get ahead. In a competitive equilibrium you always pay 10 times more for the smartest model.
He leaves open whether tasks will saturate so a smarter model is no longer needed, and he thinks that is very hard while companies are actually competing. Some tasks may saturate anyway. The real test is whether software ships faster, gets better, and wins in the marketplace, and that pressure pushes teams to the more intelligent model. Progress can still slow when companies are not spending more tokens, so they either increase prices or go broad. In his experience pricing holds, and the competitive equilibrium still means everyo
-
What Does Martin Casado Think of Network Effects?
Martin Casado calls the fuss over network effects a personal annoyance and a pedantic habit. Defensibility is not really worth talking about most of the time. In early discussions on models, investors would never invest in a model because it would never accrue value and was not defensible. A model still accrues a lot of value as long as the market is growing and the market is large.
When a market is growing, companies do not want to compete. A lot of new white space gets created, and they try to move into other white space. Talking about defensibility is a second or third order thing. When a market is slowing down or shrinking, it normally consolidates anyway, independent of moats.
Investo
-
What Are the Four Venture Investing Mindsets?
Martin Casado names four mindsets people bring to venture and private-market tech investing: a traditional finance mindset, productive investors, frontier investing, and speculative investors. A decade and hundreds of deals showed that investors in the same discussion were not communicating well.
The traditional finance mindset treats the market a business is entering, and its finances, as the correct proxy for the health of the whole company. Software-as-a-service metrics and the size of the market stand in for the business. Growth investors use it, and more early-stage Series A investors do too, which is a little discordant so early. Productive investors believe they are buying a producti
Invest Like the Best with Patrick O'Shaughnessy · Cliff Sosin - Owning the Complements to Intelligence
-
Why Is Cliff Sosin Comfortable With 80% of His Portfolio in Carvana?
Cliff Sosin is comfortable keeping most of his portfolio in Carvana because he thinks about the stake the way an owner thinks about a company, not the way a study of price swings tells a typical investor to diversify. Patrick O'Shaughnessy describes the portfolio as roughly 80 percent Carvana, a vacations holding, and about 5 percent Meta, with one position at 80 percent, and Sosin agrees. Asked whether an AI sizing tool would put less in Carvana, he says he is underweight and that it should be 90 percent.
He would not hold this much if he did not believe Carvana's infrastructure and brand left few scenarios that work out really badly. He compares it to finding Walmart, Home Depot, or Faste
-
Will AI Agents Push Customers to the Lowest-cost Provider?
Cliff Sosin says that once people hand routine choices to an AI agent, the customer moves to the lowest-cost provider. He puts decisions on a spectrum. An insured bank deposit can be delegated: take the highest rate. A favorite sweater cannot. The agent can find options, and the person still has to choose. Garbage collection, in his stylized example, sits near the deposit. A cheaper hauler still struggles to win a switch today, because many people do not know what they pay and will not spend attention on it. An agent can hear an offer of 50 cents a month, confirm the trash still gets picked up, and switch.
A second effect is coordination on a street. One truck serving every house is cheaper
-
Who Makes Money When AI Intelligence Gets Cheap?
Cliff Sosin says the businesses that benefit when intelligence gets cheap own the complements to intelligence, not the intelligence itself. Assume everyone already has very good intelligence, and ask what is left. The complements he names are data, attention, affection, physical proximity, scale, and, more cynically, regulatory capture. A product that is only a hardened piece of intelligence can be hurt, because a general model does that work. A company held back by the cost of intelligence can be helped once that cost falls. A company whose profits depend on customers being too tired to shop around can be hurt.
Meta is his example. He calls the core business personalized TV. It used to be
-
Why Should Kids Learn Math Without AI?
Cliff Sosin argues that children should learn foundational skills apart from models so they can direct a model. You cannot ask a model to treat a problem as a stochastic process unless you already know what a stochastic process is. A model could teach the term, but figuring it out that way adds a lot of friction. You do not have to work out the math, but you do have to know what it is.
Foundational skills build on one another, and children have to be able to do them without models. The point is not that later work will happen without models. If they cannot multiply, matrix multiplication is very hard to understand. They need not perform matrix multiplication especially well. They do need a
-
How Does Cheap AI Affect Income?
Cliff Sosin tells two stories about how cheap, ubiquitous intelligence affects wealth and income distribution. One story, already widely discussed, holds that income concentrates: people made money on labs, data, and NVIDIA, with increasing returns to small groups.
The counterargument starts with rent takers. A software company that charges bowling alleys gets smoked. Losing the rent lowers the cost of bowling and raises living standards for everyone who bowls. Spending on bowling is a small share of a high income and a larger share of income for people who make less, so the effect flattens income. When the little rent pieces go away, corporate profits decline. Money the average American gi
-
How Much of the Economy Moved Into AI?
Cliff Sosin says American capital markets redeployed 3% of GDP into a highly speculative AI venture on the turn of a dime. Worry about a decline in American dynamism ran into a market that moved capital at a scale and speed no other country has matched. He allows the fitting share might be two or six.
An inability to move investment into productive resources can bind productivity growth, especially when technology is advancing quickly. Capital spending is tied to people doing different work. Every day, people wake up and go to Pennsylvania to build a data center. The buildout depends on infrastructure that moved an enormous amount of capital.
Taking risk on speculative ventures and slicing
-
Does a Person Working With an AI Model Beat a Person or a Model Alone?
Cliff Sosin says a person working with a model now beats either one alone. Computer-aided chess had a long stretch of freestyle chess, where the human plus the program out-competed the human alone and out-competed the computer alone, because each side thought differently and the mix was synergistic. Investing is in that era.
A person still understands things a model misses by having lived a life, and not everything is on the internet. Using a model and then judging makes better judgments while the gap remains, which he thinks will last a while. Later the gap can shrink until it does not matter. Models will not predict the future, because the future is intrinsically unpredictable, but the mo
-
Why Does AI Infrastructure Get Overbuilt?
Cliff Sosin says AI infrastructure gets pushed until it is overbuilt because a strong price signal is what makes a buildout of a huge technology possible at all. Super smart, talented people are focusing their lives on the project, and they will make, and deserve, lots of money. Without that money, people would not keep pushing.
American society looks like a household saving money for a house. Electricians, plumbers, and other resources go into the AI infrastructure, so costs rise elsewhere in the economy. The work keeps going because nobody really knows the right stopping point, and it continues until the buildout is overdone. Lead times and a winner's curse mean the last person to stop wi
-
When Does AI Reach Its Limit?
Cliff Sosin says the limit arrives after the papers are finished. Models read all the papers and figure out connections that a person who had read all three papers and thought about them would have seen, though nobody had. All kinds of great results fall out of the reading. At some point the mining of published work is done, and what is left is a hypothesis about how to think about things outside what people already know. Even a super smart model will not necessarily be better at guessing the hypothesis. The model will still guess better than the smartest person, but the smartest person's odds are super low anyway.
The model can come up with great ideas for experiments, and the experiments
-
When Do Price Cuts Shrink a Market?
Cliff Sosin says a market shrinks once further price cuts stop creating enough demand, and a price of zero takes the market size to zero. Jevons paradox is only a narrow spot on a U-shaped demand curve, and markets in general take that shape. When a product is terrible, there is no demand. As the product gets better, people will pay a lot but will not buy very much. As the price goes down, the market grows.
Moving information once cost a huge amount, and people moved very little of it. A series of innovations cut that cost a lot, the amount of information moved rose sharply, and the market grew for a long time. Growth then stopped. The cost kept falling and the market kept shrinking. Cogent
-
Why Can't Even Superintelligent AI Predict the Future?
Cliff Sosin says even superintelligent AI cannot predict most of what people want to know, because complex systems amplify tiny errors until a forecast falls apart. Intelligence fills in a thin scattering of facts. Mathematics can reach a closed form. Weather, mixing cream into coffee, and how groups of people interact cannot. A simulation carries error in the starting conditions or in each truncated step, and that error builds.
The weather model behind chaos theory is the concrete case. A forecaster ran it, reset it, and ran it again. The second run matched at first and then diverged. A few days out, one forecast was 70 degrees and sunny and the other was 20 degrees and pouring. The only c
Invest Like the Best with Patrick O'Shaughnessy · Christina Cacioppo - Building an Enduring Software Company in the…
-
Why Is Pay for Vanta's Top People Up 10x?
Christina Cacioppo says total pay for the top person at Vanta is probably ten times what that seat paid five years ago, and she thinks it should be higher. Her rule is that you never pay the top people enough. You should always try, and you will not get there. Comp bands are a joke, because the survey data is already wrong. The number that matters is whatever those people are being offered now. What she is paying for is a high-context person who knows the company, the customers, and the domain, makes reasonable decisions, fixes the bad ones, and keeps moving.
The rate is still accelerating. The brake would be investors pushing back on dilution and stock-based pay. The industry had that argu
-
Why Is Vanta Paying for Customers' AI Tokens?
Christina Cacioppo says Vanta is eating the AI token cost and taking a lower margin. Customers notice a markup and compare it with the model itself, so marking tokens up is a comparison the product loses. About 25 percent of customers are already in the flow where an agent goes off and does the work, and she wants that at 75 percent. Retention and the experience come first. Price can wait until the usage is real.
The end state she wants is outcome pricing, getting paid for the result. Everyone she talks to wants that, and she likes the alignment from her years teaching microeconomics. Patrick O'Shaughnessy separates a closed support ticket, an output, from the outcome the customer actually
-
How Did Vanta Lose Its Famous Billboard?
Christina Cacioppo says Vanta lost the billboard spot the company was known for because the deal was a placement order, not a multi-year contract. She had told podcast listeners the contract was locked up for years. It was not.
The billboard got famous, and people kept asking how Vanta did billboards. Referrals to one agency contact added up to millions of dollars of business. Years later, at a dinner, a startup friend said they had just signed the same spot. The supposed contract was written in crayon: there was no real contract. The contact called it a placement order. The other company paid more, so the spot was swapped out underneath Vanta. She went to that founder ready to pay almost a
-
Why Does AI Help Security Chiefs Get Budget?
Christina Cacioppo says security chiefs are much more likely to get budget for an enterprise risk overhaul today because the request is attached to AI. Over the past couple of years, Vanta has spent more time with government at the federal, state, and local levels inside the U.S. and outside the U.S. There is an appetite for modernization. It is a big stated priority of the current U.S. administration, and the same appetite exists outside the U.S. AI created more FOMO in government officials. They may have always known they did not have modern processes or modern software, but the gap feels more of an imperative now.
The conversation around AI has changed the priority and raised the priorit
-
How Do AI Models Change Security Bug Priority?
Christina Cacioppo says AI models are far more persistent than people, so issues that look low severity on their own get chained into a real finding, and teams have to fix problems as fast as they find them.
Models will try nine quadrillion things where a person would give up after 9000. Some of what they surface are zero days people had not found before, or had not found in public. The bigger change is chaining 17 benign or only benign-ish issues into one real result. An OpenAI talk at RSA about Hugging Face showed the same pattern: persistence, then joining items a person would call low severity and plan to fix in 90 days. Someone would still wait 90 days and do other work first. Machines
-
Are French Software Companies Using Chinese Models?
Christina Cacioppo learned that a lot of the French software companies in Paris are using Chinese models predominantly. She was with customers in France a couple of weeks ago, and the pattern surprised her. She first thought the reason was nationalism, maybe an anti-American feeling, and she suggested that out loud. Someone corrected her very quickly: absolutely not.
The companies had all switched to Chinese models when Trump closed Fable off to non-Americans. They realized there is a huge business continuity risk. They cannot trust that if they build a business on one American model, the model will always be available. So they stopped doing that.
French software companies in Paris describ
-
How Do You Get a Team to Adopt AI?
Christina Cacioppo says the hard part of adopting AI that has paid off is simply getting people to use it, with personal use coming first.
Building something for the company on your own does not matter. What matters is knowing where the models are good, where they are bad, and what a harness means, and doing that check at least every two weeks because the tools change so quickly. A visceral sense of what works and what does not is what lets a leader answer when someone says they will fire all of the SDRs because they built one agent, and press on where that claim is true and where it is false. The aim is to get as many other people as possible into the same hands-on work.
A year ago, peopl
-
Why Is an 80% Growth Software Business Worth Less Than a Faster One?
Christina Cacioppo says a business growing 80 percent with 80 percent margins returns more cash over a long stretch than one growing 160 percent with 30 percent margins, yet the faster business is valued at three or four times the multiple, and the gap can reach ten times. She calls living through that cognitive dissonance.
Patrick O'Shaughnessy sets up the market side: Vanta is still growing very fast, with the high margins that looked like the best model four years ago, and nothing about that got worse, yet the multiple on a business like it is a third or a quarter of the old level. She still wants to do what customers want, which may or may not be token pricing that pushes a company towa
-
What Does Vanta Do for Companies?
Christina Cacioppo started Vanta about eight years ago to help companies build and earn trust. Building trust means starting security programs and compliance programs, or maturing the ones a company already has, then earning credit from customers through audits such as a SOC 2, ISO 27001, or HIPAA, plus security questionnaires and trust centers. The bet was that a security company could grow by helping companies put security in place because customers were already asking for it.
Vanta was initially known for SOC 2. A billboard on the 101 led her to joke that the company was mostly known for making billboards. The work started very compliance and audit centric. The audit was always just one
Invest Like the Best with Patrick O'Shaughnessy · David Vélez - Building Nubank and the Future of Global Banking
-
Why Do Founder-led Companies Keep Outperforming?
David Vélez says founder-led companies continue to outperform for decades because, when a leader has to choose, the founder mode wins, especially in big technology shifts where the founder's assets show up more clearly than the advantages of a chief executive.
A founder and a chief executive are different functions that do not necessarily fit together. The founder is impatient, carries a huge sense of urgency, and wants to move extremely fast. The chief executive has to be more patient, more systematic about decisions, and bring systems thinking into scaling the organization. The two sides can conflict: impatient on one end, patient on the other. Chief executives tend to be better managers