How Much Does BRCA1 Raise Breast Cancer Risk?
Siddhartha Mukherjee says a BRCA1 mutation is a shove mutation: it puts a person at a ninefold or tenfold risk, above the normal population, of hereditary breast cancer at an early age. He calls BRCA2 a shove mutation as well.
He says the single genes already known still cover only about a third, maybe a fourth, of hereditary breast cancer. The rest, he says, is probably hundreds of genes, each pushing risk by a small percentage. He calls those nudge mutations. He also says the old figure, 5 percent of mutations being hereditary, is no longer 5 percent.
From the transcript
We're now talking only about hereditary breast cancer. If you take all the single genes that we know increase the risk of hereditary breast cancer, that still only covers a fraction, about a third, maybe a fourth, of hereditary breast cancer. So, the question is, what's the other... So, again, remember we're talking about just hereditary breast cancer.
So, what's the other whatever percentage? And the answer now is that that other fraction in hereditary breast cancer, not breast cancer caused by random mutations, or by exposure to environments, etc., is a combination of multiple genes, not one, not two, but probably hundreds of genes that are pushing your risk by a small percentage. So, the way I try to describe this to my patients is I say, in hereditary cancers, there are two kinds of mutations.