What Percent of Cancer Mutations Are Random?
Peter Attia says about two-thirds of cancer mutations, 66-ish percent, are purely random. Recalling the math from a 2015 paper in Science, he puts about 5 percent of mutations down as hereditary and on the order of 30 percent down to environmental triggers or carcinogens.
The paper looked at cancers by tissue type. Hereditary mutations include BRCA1 and many others talked about less often. Smoking raises the risk of a mutation, and lots of UV light can cause one too. In 2017 the authors published another paper that revisited the result. The idea that stuck was that cancer is a bad luck disease: the healthiest person can do everything right and still get a random mutation, and Peter Attia says that pattern may explain up to two-thirds of the mutations seen. He says cardiovascular disease does not look like that in someone who has managed cholesterol and blood pressure.
The oncology community was divided on the 2015 paper. Peter Attia asks how to take the bad-luck observation and do something about it.
From the transcript
I mean, Sid, that's fantastic because everything you've covered there is sort of where we want to go, with one exception. We didn't touch on AI, which we will touch on, I'm sure. But let's go back and look at something that we learned in the last 15 years, courtesy of Brett Vogelstein and his colleagues. So in 2015, they published a paper in Science.
Both you and I remember this very well. The entire oncology community was sort of divided a little bit on this. In 2017, they came out with another paper that kind of revisited it. But the gist of the paper was that if you looked at all cancers by tissue type, if I'm remembering the math correctly, Sid, about 5% of the mutations, because, again, cancer is a genetic disease.