Should Everyone Get a Blood Test for Cancer?
Siddhartha Mukherjee says blood tests that can find some cancers early are probably not going to work if they are used on everyone, with no selection for people at high risk or for people who have already had cancer.
He says those tests lead to false positives, extra biopsies, and more follow-up tests, and that they are unlikely to lower deaths from cancer. Used in people who carry genetic mutations that raise risk, or in people who have had cancer before, he says the same tests may yield very important results. That "may" is his, not a promise that the tests work.
From the transcript
Yeah, there's probably a big lag. It's always a lag. It's always a five to ten year lag. So that's all we know about prevention. Big deals. We can talk about each of those individual pieces that I spoke about separately, and each one of them is a full conversation. All right, let's talk about early detection. We know that there are tests in patients, for instance, blood tests that will enable the early detection of some cancers.
We know that if you just, at least for now, we know that if you just take those tests and unloosen them on a general population, so without selecting for high -risk people, without selecting for people who have had cancer before, we know that those tests are probably not going to work. They're going to lead to false positives. They're going to lead to extra biopsies and extra tests, more tests, following tests, et cetera.