Smash Notes

Back to Ep. 218: Work vs. Meaning.

Why Does Getting Lost in a Song Still Count as Solitude?

Input from another mind means linguistic input, such as reading something or hearing someone talking or seeing someone talking, which fires up social circuits and ends solitude. You can get lost in a song and still count that as solitude, but it should not be your only type of solitude.

Transcript

Ep. 218: Work vs. Meaning ·

From the transcript

All right. That's all the backdrop, Michael's question then is nuanced because he says, well, music that was generated by another mind. So you're encountering an artifact that was generated by another mind, does that defy solitude? Or can you still be in a state of solitude when listening to music? And I think the answer there is, you can so when I say input from another mind, this is a linguistic definition of input.

So processing linguistically input from other minds, you're reading something or hearing someone talking or seeing someone talking. That's really what fires up all those social circuits and gets you out of a state of solitude. So I think you can get lost in a song and we can count that as solitude. However, however, it should not be your only type of solitude because if we're going to get fiddly about this, there's really two different types of solitude.

See in transcript

Deep Questions with Cal Newport

More from this episode

  1. Why Does the 1960s Backlash Reject a Lifelong Corporate Job?The 1960s produced the first backlash to the 1950s, the counterculture backlash, seen in the beat movement and then the Hippie movement.
  2. Why Does Follow Your Passion Become Career Advice?Follow your passion is the phrase for the idea that your work can be your primary source of meaning.
  3. How Do You Connect a Life Vision to a Specific Job?Use three properties of a job, income, location, and work type, to support the big vision. Income is how much income it generates.
  4. What Happened When They Moved to Tofino to Escape the Rat Race?They moved to Tofino on the pacific coast of the large rural Vancouver island, off the west coast of british Columbia.
  5. What Happened When Friends at Dartmouth Chose Their Careers?He really thinks 50% plus of his friends at Dartmouth went to Harvard law school.
  6. How Do You Stop Using YouTube as a Crutch After Work?Take a 30 day break from optional digital technologies and aggressively experiment to find activities that fit your life and offer a real source of meaning…
  7. Why Did No One Know What to Do With the New Middle-class Mode of Work?Reading Bennett shows that no one knew what to do with this new mode of work.
  8. Why Do You Skip a Daily Journal?You do not do any daily structured daily writing.
  9. What Happened When Kurt Steiner Dedicated His Life to Rock Skipping?Kurt Steiner dedicated his life to rock skipping.

People

More answers like this

More with Cal Newport

Related episodes

Plays from this note through the rest of the episode.

Weekly highlights

One letter a week.

The notes worth hearing, with the minute they were said.