Back to #2562 - Dan McClellan, with Dan McClellan.
How Does First Enoch Contradict Itself?
First Enoch contradicts itself because the stories about angels coming down get repeated a couple of different times as it is a collection of five different books. The Book of the Watchers, the Parables of Enoch, and the Animal Apocalypse tell overlapping stories in ways that do not align perfectly so First Enoch is internally inconsistent.
From the transcript
The stories get told over and over in some slightly different ways. And then also it contradicts a lot of the stuff that Christians are finding in the New Testament and in their Hebrew Bible. and so it was, it was becoming unpopular in the second and into the third century. But by the time we get to our Codex Sinaiticus and our Codex Vaticanus in the fourth century, in the middle to the late fourth century, there's no sign of first Enoch.
How does first Enoch contradict itself?
the stories about the angels coming down gets repeated a couple of different times, because it's actually not a single narrative. It's a collection of five different books. Traditions. You have the Book of the Watchers, you have, the Parables of Enoch, you have the Animal Apocalypse, which is basically retelling the story, but everybody's an animal.