Back to #2562 - Dan McClellan, with Dan McClellan.
Why Do Some Scholars Think an Early Genesis Had No Flood Story?
The Epic of Gilgamesh sends a traveler to find Utnapishtim, who survived the flood, so the flood has already happened in that epic. Atrahasis is another version of the flood story. Sumerian king lists predate the introduction of a flood story.
Genesis was circulating in a version that had no flood story until someone put one in, probably around the sixth to fifth century BCE. Noah is a horticulturist in the oldest tales. Genesis four names progenitors of people who live in tents, play the lyre and the harp, and work in metals. The writer does not know the lines are supposed to all die.
From the transcript
So you've got a few different stories of the flood. And in the Epic of Gilgamesh, he's going to find Utnapishtim, who was the one who survived the flood. So the flood has already happened in the Gilgamesh Epic. but like Atrahasis is another version of that story. But if you go all the way back to the Sumerian king lists, We have king lists that predate the introduction of a, a flood story.
And in fact, a lot of scholars think that Genesis actually was circulating in a version that didn't have a flood story.
Until,
yeah, until someone put it in there. And
when do they think that happened?
that's a great question. I, they probably date it to somewhere around the sixth to fifth century BCE, because Noah is a horticulturist in the, the oldest tales of, of what's going on here. And there's no indication of a flood. In fact, if you go in Genesis four, you have some patriarchs who are mentioned. And it's like, and this was the progenitor of those who live in tents.