Can a Person Live Without B Cells?
Siddhartha Mukherjee says human beings can live with their B cells killed. The CAR T cells aimed at B-cell leukemias and B-cell lymphomas do not kill only the cancer. They kill all B cells.
He says that fact is why the treatment can work, and that the reasons, which he calls evolutionary among others, are not known. He says CAR T cells should be thought of as lineage specific and tissue specific, not cancer specific. A woman can live without mammary tissue, without ovaries, or without an endometrium, so the same approach would kill that tissue, not only the tumor.
From the transcript
So the CAR T cells that kill B cell leukemias and lymphomas don't just kill B cell leukemias and lymphomas. They kill all B cells. I'm going to repeat that fact. They don't kill B cell leukemias and lymphomas. They kill all B cells. And it just happens to be the case, for reasons that we don't know, evolutionary reasons and others, that human beings can live with B cells killed.
The problem, and that's great, for B cell leukemias, B cell lymphomas and other cancers. But we can, we can, a woman can live without any mammary tissue. So why can't we just, yeah, let's kill every breast tissue in her body when she has breast cancer. A woman could live without her ovaries, if, I mean, pleasant thought, but a woman could live without her endometrium.