Can Surgery Cure Cancer in the Tail of the Pancreas?
Siddhartha Mukherjee says surgery can cure some pancreatic cancers that start in the tail. He has patients who have lived 10 years after a Whipple when the tumor sat far from the crowded head of the pancreas and was found incidentally.
The pancreas is a long organ shaped like a leaf in the gut. Cancers in the head sit closer to the intestines and tend to show up with pain and jaundice. Cancers in the tail sit farther away and tend to be found incidentally. Mukherjee says tail tumors are less involved with other organs, so they are an anatomically distinct cancer and some patients can live longer after surgery. The head is where intestines run downward and blood vessels cross. He compares it to a traffic accident at the most complicated intersection below the neck, and an accident there does not resolve easily. Peter Attia had said probably only 5% of all comers are surgically cured, and asked whether the 95% caught too late could be found earlier. Mukherjee agrees. The outcome depends on the anatomy.
From the transcript
The other argument would be, the whole steadying argument would be, no, if you catch this at an early, early, early stage one and you do the appropriate Whipple procedure, a subset of these patients can live. And yes, it's probably only 5% that will be surgically cured of all comers. But if we could detect of those 95% who were caught too late, could we catch them earlier? Where do you sit on this spectrum? So look, I mean, so I agree with you on this.
I think, so as you know, the pancreas is a long organ. It looks like a big leaf. It's sitting sort of in your gut.
Fundamentally speaking, there are two kinds of pancreatic cancer head, the ones that are in the head, one in the tail. So if you think about it as a leaf, the ones that are in the head are closer to the parts of your intestines. The ones that are in your tail are further away. The tail ones tend to be detected incidentally. The head ones tend to be detected with pain and jaundice and other things.