Is Osteoarthritis an Obesity Disease?
Siddhartha Mukherjee says he has never believed osteoarthritis is an obesity disease. People who are not obese get osteoarthritis, and the disease can appear in joints that do not carry body weight.
His laboratory discovered the first osteoarthritic stem cells and published the finding in Cell, then in Nature and Nature Medicine. Knees and hips, the weight-bearing limbs, do get osteoarthritis, and people have hips and knees replaced. The pattern is usually women who are obese. Mukherjee says the explanation seems backwards, in the way much of medicine has treated women: obesity, therefore a weight-bearing problem, therefore a weight disease. A woman with no obesity can still have massive inflamed nodes in her hands. The hand is not a weight-bearing joint. Some patients have degeneration of the upper neck joints and come in with upper neck pain and shoulder pain, and they are not obese.
Mukherjee says osteoarthritis is almost certainly a combination of two problems. One, which his lab has been a big proponent of, is a balance in the stem cells that grow cartilage in the joints over time.
From the transcript
Well, so osteoarthritis is my neck of the woods because my laboratory discovered the first osteoarthritic stem cells. We published that in cell and then subsequently in nature and nature medicine. And I have never believed from the beginning of the time I began to study osteoarthritis. I never believed that osteoarthritis was an obesity disease.
There are not obese people who have osteoarthritis. There are obese people who have osteoarthritis. It's much larger. But the idea, there was something kind of like it didn't make sense. And also it was sort of like, let's blame the victim. Let's say fat people get osteoarthritis. And let's just say, oh, you know, that's a fat people problem.
And it just didn't make sense. It doesn't make sense for many reasons. Look, I'll tell you some of the reasons. So, yes, of course, the weight -bearing limbs, the knees, the hips, get osteoarthritis. And people complain about knees and hips. And they get hips replaced, knees replaced, etc. Great. Fine. Makes sense. That's usually people who are obese, usually women who are obese.