Why Does David Tisch Think High Ownership at Seed Is Overrated?
David Tisch says trying to buy 10 to 20 percent of a true outlier in the seed round, and beat the best venture firms to do it, is a bet he has never understood. Those firms spent decades building what they stand for, and founders already want them in the deal. Since COVID they are more concentrated on seed, more accessible, and more efficient, and founders know how to reach them. A competitive early round that used to draw 3 to 5 term sheets can now draw 10 to 15.
The claim that a concentrated manager wins 90 percent of the deals they want is, in his view, total BS. The real rate is about 20 percent. A fund that needs 30 companies at 10 percent ownership has to offer that deal to 120 or 150 companies to fill those 30. Owning 10 percent of 30 names does not mean those were the 30 the firm most wanted. The best companies do not always make it into that portfolio. Wider checks are how Box Group gets into more of the companies it is actually excited about.
From the transcript
You have to be in the outliers. The idea that me or you, to pick on both of us, are going to be able to find and buy 10 to 20% of a true outlier in the seed round and beat the rest of the market, which I truly think a lot of, not all, are great at their jobs. You're going to fight them head to head. and convince the founder to pick you, and that's the company that matters, I think it's a lot of steps that you have to believe to get that business right.
And so I've never understood trying to compete head to head against who I would deem to be the best vcs in the world and i think these are brands and these are people that have spent decades building what their organization stands for and attracting the best set of founders to want them in their deal and i think those multi-stage firms that have been around for a long time are really really good at seed investing in a way that they weren't before, huh? They're more concentrated, focused on it, and they're more accessible, and they're more efficient, and the market's more efficient.