Does Pro Rata Help Founders More Than Firms?
David Tisch says having pro rata in the documents helps the founder more than it helps the firm. Early-stage funds that say they do not need pro rata and will give it away are selling marketing garbage. The right to invest in later rounds is earned whether the documents grant it or not, and it is not that black and white.
If a founder asks a firm to step back and the firm says no, the firm is getting into a fight it is likely to lose. The loss can be financial, because some mechanism can be used to remove the pro rata, or, more importantly, reputational, because the founder gets angry and stops liking the firm. Taking that reputational risk is on the firm.
Funds that follow into the A and the B are happy to squash an earlier investor any way they can. The more pro rata sits in the documents, the more leverage a founder has to negotiate the next round. When a new firm wants 22% and 6% of the cap table still needs pro rata, the founder can tell the follow-on investor the ownership map does not work and ask to redo the terms.
From the transcript
Is there one that you think of first there? I think of a lot. But I think we're like incredibly fortunate to be in business with that founder at the earliest stage. And I think our job is to like continue to help them in the ways that they ask us to help them and make our customers who are the founders happy. David, is pro rata right? Now, like, do I think, do I think a bunch of the VCs that are the early stage VCs that are out there saying like, we don't need pro rata.
We're going to like give it like, it's all marketing garbage. It's just nonsense. I can write a blog post too. I just don't believe that that it's that black and white. I believe the right to invest in subsequent rounds is earned. Whether you have it in the documents or not, it's earned. There are multiple factors that go into it. So having it in the documents, to me, is more helpful for the founder than for you as a firm.