When Does Hannah Knapp Calm Rather Than Notice?
Hannah Knapp tells Stewart Alsop on Crazy Wisdom that the choice between regulation and awareness depends on how strong the emotion is and on the context. Alone on the cushion, she stays with awareness. She notices whatever arises and lets the wave pass, because nobody else is affected.
When her toddler is in a full-blown moment and awareness alone will not let the feeling run its course, she regulates, because the last thing she wants is to end up yelling. She uses affect labeling. She says, out loud, that she is feeling angry, and that often drops the charge the way a breath does. She separates that from Buddhist practice.
From the transcript
I do. And it for me. It depends in a lot of ways, on the intensity of the emotion and on the context. So if I'm just sitting in meditation, I'm definitely just gonna be an awareness. I'm gonna just notice whatever is happening ride whenever wave because it's just me and my emotion. I'm not impacting anybody. When I win my toddler take the stake there is like the last thing I wanna do is end up yelling on top.
And so if I'm feeling like just being aware of the emotion isn't allowing it to diffuse and run its course than I'm going to take steps to regulate, right, I'm going to say I'm gonna art. I'm gonna use affect labeling. I'm going to say I'm feeling angry, and often that makes it just like we were just talking about it with breathing.