Smash Notes

Back to Tobi Lütke on the AI agent revolution and future of Shopify, with Tobi Lütke.

Why Does Pessimism Lead to Zero-sum Thinking?

Tobi Lütke says pessimism leads to zero-sum thinking because, once pessimism counts as sophisticated, people take fewer opportunities, growth fades, and appreciation of opportunity fades, so the strategy becomes competing for what already exists.

Humans need a frontier and work best when opportunity is present. Without a frontier or enough perceived growth, competing for what already exists is the correct strategy. An environment where zero-sum thinking predominates feels entirely different from one where positive-sum thinking predominates and people go for new markets and new ideas. The gap is the biggest difference imaginable, and the two sit far apart on a very long spectrum. Joining a startup that is winning is intoxicating because the growth is obvious. A small niche where everyone agrees optimism is acceptable usually takes the form of a company or a startup. When reversion to the mean makes pessimism the sophisticated stance, fewer opportunities get taken, growth and appreciation of opportunity fall away, and zero-sum thinking and competition return quickly.

Grokipedia·Tobi Lütke

Transcript

Tobi Lütke on the AI agent revolution and future of Shopify ·

From the transcript

Like and then do the stuff I have to do easier and make my life a couple percent better. And so it's quite fantastical. It's a wonderful time to be in tech. Do you think that optimism is just because of the feeling of invention and invention as a thing that naturally gives humans optimism? Yeah, I believe that's exactly it. I think it's you hit the nail on the head there.

I think humans need a frontier of sorts because I think we work best when there's opportunity because obviously, again, theoretically, if there's no frontier or not enough perceived growth around us, fundamentally, the correct strategy ends up becoming competing for what's already exists. And it sounds like a small thing, but the difference in what it feels like to be in an environment of where zero -sum thinking predominates or positive -sum thinking, where the opportunity is about and like people are going for new markets, new ideas.

See in transcript

Sources with Alex Heath

More from this episode

  1. Why Did Shopify and Amazon Split on Muse?Tobi Lütke says Shopify and Amazon split on Muse because they have spent 20 years on different ideas of commerce, not because one of them is simply right.
  2. Why Does Selling in More Places Make Shopify More Valuable?Tobi Lütke says Shopify is known for online stores, but merchants use it in many other situations, and Shopify becomes more valuable the more places people…
  3. What Are People Buying Through AI Agents?Tobi Lütke says people are buying more through AI agents, and the change that matters is the kind of purchase, not the growth rate.
  4. What Does Tobi Lütke Think About AI Risk?Tobi Lütke thinks the positive effects of AI are going to be vastly higher than the negative effects, and his PDOOM is zero.
  5. Are More Shopify Stores Opening Than Ever?Tobi Lütke says more Shopify storefronts are being opened now than ever, and the curve is going really, really well. The people opening them are younger.
  6. Why Is Europe More Cynical About AI Than America?Tobi Lütke says Europe is more cynical about AI than America, not simply more negative, because people there still reason from an early ChatGPT install while…
  7. What Did Shopify's AI Memo Require?Tobi Lütke says that once he is convinced something has to happen, he can do what a professional manager hired into the job cannot.
  8. Who Should Pay for AI Shopping Agents?Tobi Lütke is fatalistic about who pays for AI shopping agents.
  9. Why Do People Start Shopify Stores on a Lunch Break?Tobi Lütke says Shopify wants entrepreneurship to be more common and easier to reach, closer to a plan A than only a plan B.
  10. Why Does a Company Have to Be Too Good to Ignore?Tobi Lütke says a successful company has to be too good to ignore, and a fantastical career comes from skills and aptitudes that make a person too good to…
  11. Why Is a Paid Shopping Assistant a Breach of Trust?Tobi Lütke says a shopping assistant that gets paid to choose products is a breach of trust. People want agents that work for them.
  12. What Is the Claw Agent Tobi Lütke Runs at Home?Tobi Lütke runs a completely local Claw in his house, on a rack like the one Lulu and Christian built, with one of Dell's GB300s inside, and the rack is fully…

People

More answers like this

More with Alex Heath

Related episodes

Plays from this note through the rest of the episode.

Weekly highlights

One letter a week.

The notes worth hearing, with the minute they were said.