Back to #2571 - Jimmy Carr, with Jimmy Carr.
How Does Tim Urban Rank Ways of Thinking?
Jimmy Carr describes Tim Urban's ladder for how people think: a scientist, a sports fan, a lawyer, then a zealot. What's Our Problem, one of his favorite books of the last 10 years, is about how you think, not about left and right. New evidence would change a scientist's opinion. A religious zealot will not change and stays ride or die.
Between the scientist and the zealot, a sports fan likes the team but will not want a win that comes from cheating, because the rules of the game matter more. Election fraud should look like horseshit even to someone on that side. A lawyer will speak for the team no matter what without really believing it, and the zealot above the lawyer really believes everything.
He cares where people sit on the spectrum more than old left and right labels, and he frames the split as freedom versus authoritarian. Thomas Sowell's idea is that politics has no solutions, only trade-offs: you can have safety, but you cannot have safety and freedom together, so the lines between them have to be found. Debate tries to own the other person and win. Deliberation agrees on a problem and talks around it in a broad way.
From the transcript
I just think the overall structure of the way our society is formulated. We've got this ridiculous binary. It's ridiculous red versus blue narrative where there's good guys and bad guys and whoever they are is dependent upon where you find yourself and what ideology. You know, Tim Urban you ever had him on the show. No, he wrote this book called what's our problem.
It's like one of my favorite books the last 10 years. Right. And so the book is it's not about left and right. It's about how you think about things. So Tim Urban's theory is right. You can either think like a scientist where you go right new evidence would change my opinion. Okay, and you're very right on emotional about it or like at the top level you think like a zealot like a religious zealot.