Back to #2571 - Jimmy Carr, with Jimmy Carr.
What Is the Difference Between an Artist and an Entertainer?
Jimmy Carr says the difference is what the person needs from the crowd. Robbie Williams told him he is an entertainer in the pure sense: if you do not love him, he does not love himself. Comics may be better at not caring what people think, because they are not entertainers in that pure sense.
An artist can be told the new record is loved and still treat the record as the point. Jimmy Carr puts Bob Dylan on that side. He writes the jokes, but he does not write the show. Joe Rogan calls the failure mode audience capture: if the work exists only to collect love and affection, the performer becomes a covers version of themselves, a hall of mirrors that reflects what the crowd is thought to want.
Saying thank you when someone loves an album is fine. Building the show around the best response is the trap.
From the transcript
Yes. Like, people are going to write things and that's okay. Yeah. But at some stage, you just have to go. And I think it's like a superpower. Not giving a fuck what other people think about you is a superpower. And if you can do that, like, I think comics may be better at it because we're not entertainers in the pure sense. I remember this thing like Robbie Williams said this thing to me.
He said, I'm an entertainer in the pure sense. If you don't love me, I don't love me. Ooh. God, I don't think of musicians as being that way. I would never think of Bob Dylan as that way. Well, I think Bob Dylan is, I think the difference between an entertainer and an artist is if you say to an artist, I love your new record. And they go, well, that's interesting, but I didn't give a fuck.