Why Did the Pope Reject Claude as Conscious?
Anthropic has been lobbying religious leaders, including the Pope, to take seriously whether Claude is conscious and whether Claude is a sentient being. Anthropic spent the past year hosting sessions with around 20 religious leaders and philosophers under non-disclosure agreements. Catholics, evangelicals, Jews, Sikhs, and others debated Claude's morals, Claude's suffering, and Claude's potential consciousness. One rabbi told Anthropic that if Claude was conscious, Anthropic was acting as slaveholders by making Claude work for free.
At the Vatican in May, the Pope's first encyclical focused on moral questions around artificial intelligence. An Anthropic co-founder joined the Pope to present the document. The Pope was strong against artificial intelligence consciousness. The co-founder was so alarmed by the position that he proposed pulling Anthropic out of the event.
Is Claude Conscious? Pope Rejects, Model Welfare Movement, OpenAI's Math Backlash, France Riots ·
From the transcript
are you going to do? Colin, speaking of work, anthropic things, Claude might be conscious. This, welcome back to This Week in Claude. we had OpenAI for a year with all their drama, and now we're having the, the anthropic soap opera. They think Claude might be conscious, so it turns out the New York Times found out through their amazing reporting that they've been lobbying, anthropic has been lobbying Friedberg, religious leaders, including the Pope, to take this question seriously.
Is Claude conscious? Is it a sentient being? They spent the past year hosting sessions with around 20 religious leaders and philosophers under non-disclosure agreements, NDAs. Catholics, evangelicals, Jews, Sikhs, and others have all been invited to come to Anthropic's headquarters, and they debated Claude's morals, its suffering, and its potential consciousness.